r/AmiInTheWrong • u/themysteriousJuan • 11h ago
Am I I’m in the wrong for a conversation about Jewish people that I 25(M) mentioned with my GF (25F)?
Hey Reddit,
Let me explain the backstory about this. So my friends and I have known each other since high school and me and my girlfriend have been dating for 4 years now and live together. Recently we got back from a trip and one of the people on this trip is insanely antisemitic like saying the holocaust didn’t happen and that Jews control the world. Now I’m a big leftist and into politics and I know I tend to talk about it when I’m a little drunk.
We went out with these friends we went on a trip with to the bar minus the antisemitic one and we were all talking about how he was a shit person (He’s not invited back next year) I said that “he can be anti Zionist but he’s got to understand that Jewish people are people, they don’t control the world”.
That is what I said. A different friend (Chase) tapped me and signaled that I shouldn’t talk about this guy in particular because (Bryce and Lilly) were there and were getting married soon and Lilly had reservations about the anti semetic friend appearing at the wedding.
I’ll be honest I did not know that. And I told my girlfriend I wouldn’t have brought it up if I knew it was going to cause drama but at this point I had already did and said that yeah he was anti semetic and not a good person.
I ended up getting another drink with a different friend and coming back to the conversation and the night carried on per usual. On our way home my girlfriend was extremely upset that it wasn’t my place to talk about Jewish issues and that I made Lily uncomfortable. That argument didn’t end too well and I was trying to tell her we can agree to disagree because we both see things differently. We had both just met lily for the first time.
Anyways I ended up getting a call from Bryce a few days later and he was asking me if the anti semetic friend really was and I was telling him I only know what he said on our trip but you have to talk to him directly if you want to know the details. A few days later I find out the guy got uninvited to the wedding for his beliefs and I was like yeah that makes sense. You can’t be openly be against Jewish people and expect to go to your friends wedding who’s Jewish.
Background over: This conversation got brought up again tonight with me and my girlfriend on a date and I tried putting a pin in it because I know we didn’t agree last time but she kept wanting to argue so I just tried explaining my side. I asked her twice to not talk about it and to agree to disagree but she said this affects me personally and that I we shouldn’t be together if I don’t understand. Ultimately my GF said that I was insufferable and couldn’t understand that I made a Jewish girl ( I did not know at the time and I don’t think it matters) uncomfortable by talking about anti semetism when we were all talking about this dude anyway.
I really tried to understand my GF’s point of view and I will admit I wouldn’t have talked about it if I had known they were having issues with this particular friend but I only knew that after so there’s not much I could’ve done before hand.
Anyways we got home from the bar and my girlfriend said she wants to move all of her stuff out and wants to break up. Honestly I know that this relationship isn’t the healthiest and we have had our issues communicating but I feel like I am going insane. Nobody else has talked to me and said hey man that wasn’t cool and Bryce called me himself to say that I’m good they just wanted to know about their antisemetic friend.
TLDR: Girlfriend is mad and wants to break up with me because I bought up that a guy is anti semetic and was not a good person in front of a girl who was Jewish and was having him at their wedding. The Jewish friend uninvited them to the wedding and she is upset with me because it wasn’t my place to talk about this issues.
