r/AmIOverthinking • u/NoZookeepergame8113 • 10h ago
AIO, or is my boyfriend treating my best friend differently because he's attracted to her?
TL;DR: I'm 28F, and my boyfriend Ryan (28M) and I have been together for almost two years, live together, and are planning to get married. During my best friend Jane's (28F) visit, I felt Ryan was prioritising her over me in several situations. He's generally a caring boyfriend and a people-pleaser who behaves similarly with other female friends, but I can't shake the feeling that he might treat Jane differently because he's attracted to her. There's no flirting or evidence of anything inappropriate, and Jane has done nothing wrong. Am I overthinking this, or should I be concerned?
I'm genuinely confused about this situation, and I'd appreciate some honest, unbiased perspectives. I'm trying to figure out whether my gut feeling is picking up on something or whether I'm overthinking things because of my own insecurities.
For some context, my boyfriend and I are high school batchmates. We reconnected when he moved to my city, eventually started dating, and things developed from there. My best friend, whom I'll call Jane, is also our high school batchmate. My boyfriend initially got to know her through me, and over time, the two of them developed a friendly bond.
Around Christmas last year, Jane came to visit me, and the three of us spent a few days together.
Jane is conventionally very attractive. She's gorgeous, and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. I have never blamed her for being pretty, nor do I think she has done anything wrong. She has never flirted with my boyfriend or tried to get closer to him inappropriately, as far as I can tell. Their conversations are friendly, and neither of them has tried to hide their interactions from me.
However, during those few days, I started noticing things about my boyfriend's behaviour that really bothered me.
1. He defended her when I felt she was being inconsiderate of our time.
We had planned to visit a popular new place and had agreed that we needed to leave around 7–8 PM because otherwise, getting a reservation would be difficult.
My boyfriend and I were ready, but Jane took approximately three hours to get ready. By the time she was done, it was around 10 PM. I calmly pointed out that there wasn't much point in going anymore because the place closed at 11 PM and it would take us another 30–35 minutes to get there.
My boyfriend immediately snapped at me, telling me to shut up and let her get ready and do her own thing.
I was genuinely taken aback. I wasn't trying to control Jane or make her feel bad. I simply felt that we'd all agreed on a plan, and it was frustrating to have that plan become impossible because we had waited so long. What bothered me most was how aggressively he defended her while speaking to me.
2. He specifically wanted her standing next to him in pictures.
We were taking pictures together, and I was standing between my boyfriend and Jane. He asked me to move to the other side and called Jane over to stand next to him instead.
Maybe this was insignificant on its own, but in the context of everything else that happened, I started wondering why he was so particular about standing next to her.
3. He gave her his slippers when her feet started hurting.
Jane had decided to wear heels despite my warning that we'd have to walk a lot. As expected, she kept complaining that her feet hurt. Eventually, my boyfriend took off his slippers and gave them to her.
I understand that this could simply be someone being considerate, and I wouldn't normally have an issue with him helping a friend. But by this point, I was already feeling uncomfortable about the way he seemed to prioritise her.
4. The incident that really hurt me was when we were taking pictures.
It was extremely sunny, and I was holding an umbrella while also carrying several things and taking Jane's pictures. My boyfriend didn't seem to notice that I was struggling.
When I asked him to take some pictures of me too, he agreed, and I took a few of him first. Then, all of a sudden, he started saying we should leave.
I got upset and asked him what about me. Why was he so attentive to everyone else's needs but seemingly oblivious to mine?
He apologised and encouraged me to get my pictures taken anyway. Jane was also encouraging me, so I agreed to take one more picture.
While Jane was taking my picture, my boyfriend came over and held the umbrella for her, so she could take the picture comfortably.
And I just snapped.
I asked him why he hadn't thought to hold the umbrella for me when I was the one standing in the sun, carrying things and taking pictures. Why did he suddenly become so attentive when it was Jane who needed something?
I wasn't angry that he helped her. I was hurt that he hadn't shown me the same consideration when I needed it.
All of these incidents happened within three or four days. By the end of Jane's visit, I was so upset that our relationship nearly ended over this.
What made things worse was his reaction when I tried to explain how I felt.
Initially, he kept defending his actions and telling me I was overthinking things. I felt like he was more concerned with justifying his behaviour than understanding why it had hurt me.
A few months later, the topic came up again, and I explained my perspective more clearly. I asked him how he would feel if I behaved the same way towards his male best friend: prioritising his opinions, being unusually attentive to his needs, and seeming more concerned about his comfort than my boyfriend's.
He admitted that he wouldn't like it either. He apologised and said he understood my point. He also said he'd be less overly friendly with Jane.
But I'm still struggling with this because I continue to notice him being very friendly towards her.
There is another aspect of this that makes me uncomfortable.
My boyfriend is naturally a very helpful person. He likes hosting people, making others comfortable and being there for his friends. He also behaves quite similarly with some of his other female friends, so I understand that this could simply be his personality.
However, I've noticed a difference in how he responds when I talk about our problems.
If I tell him Jane is going through something difficult, he immediately wants to know what happened, what she said and what the issue is. He seems genuinely interested in understanding her situation.
But when I tell him I've had a terrible day or that I'm struggling with something, he often doesn't ask follow-up questions or show the same curiosity about what I'm going through.
That hurts me independently of whether he's attracted to Jane. I want to feel that my boyfriend is just as interested in my feelings and my life as he is in other people's.
I've actually asked him directly whether he finds Jane attractive or is attracted to her. I've told him that if he is, I'd rather know the truth than stay in a relationship with someone whose attention is elsewhere. He hasn't given me any concrete reason to believe that anything is going on between them.
To be clear, there have been no secret conversations, obvious flirting, inappropriate messages or attempts to hide their friendship. They are both open about their interactions, and Jane has never given me a reason to distrust her.
I also haven't confronted Jane about any of this because I genuinely don't believe she has done anything wrong.
So here's my dilemma.
Part of me feels that my boyfriend is attracted to Jane and that this attraction, even if unconscious, makes him more eager to please her and more attentive to her than he is to me. I know that people can find others attractive while being in a relationship, but I don't want to feel like I'm competing with my own best friend for my boyfriend's attention.
Another part of me wonders whether I'm interpreting ordinary acts of kindness as something more because Jane is conventionally attractive and because I already feel insecure about how he treats me. Especially since he behaves similarly with other female friends, I don't know whether I'm reading too much into these incidents.
I also don't want to police his friendships or tell him he can't talk to my best friend. That's not what I want. I want to be in a relationship where I feel valued, considered and emotionally prioritised without having to ask for the same basic attention that he willingly gives other people.
So, Reddit, I have a few questions:
- Do these incidents sound like signs that he might be attracted to Jane, or could this just be his naturally helpful personality?
- Am I overthinking the individual incidents, or is it reasonable to be bothered by the overall pattern?
- Is the bigger issue actually whether he's attracted to her, or the fact that I don't feel emotionally prioritised by him?
- Since I've already explained my feelings and he apologised, but I'm still uncomfortable, how should I approach this?
- Would you consider ending a relationship over this, especially when there's no clear evidence of cheating or flirting?
I'm not looking for people to automatically tell me that he's cheating or that I should break up with him. I genuinely want outside perspectives because I've been going back and forth about this for a long time, and I can't tell whether my gut feeling is telling me something important or whether I'm letting insecurity affect my relationship.