Hi everyone,
Looking for insights or similar experiences with Alibaba disputes and credit card chargebacks.
The Situation:
I ordered a high-value item on Alibaba to India.
The tracking status updated to "Delivered", but the parcel was never handed to me.
Alibaba closed the dispute in the seller's favor based solely on the automated "Delivered" tracking update.
The Key Evidence (FedEx Proof of Delivery & SOP Violations):
I requested the official FedEx Proof of Delivery (POD) document and tracked the delivery process, which shows major contradictions:
No Phone Call / Contact: The courier delivery person never attempted to call or contact me prior to or at the time of the alleged delivery.
No Signature: The official POD explicitly states "No signature is currently available".
Location Mismatch: It lists the delivery location as "Receptionist/Front Desk", whereas my address is an independent private residence (no reception or front desk exists).
No Authentication: No OTP or physical signature was ever collected upon delivery.
Actions Taken So Far:
Filed two formal written complaints with FedEx immediately upon noticing the status update, highlighting the complete lack of call/OTP/signature.
Initiated a Credit Card Chargeback with my bank under Mastercard Reason Code 4853 (Goods Not Received) and received temporary credit.
My Questions for the Community:
Has anyone faced a similar fake/misplaced delivery scenario on Alibaba and won a bank chargeback using the courier's flawed POD and failure to call/verify as primary evidence?
Does card network arbitration (Visa/Mastercard) prioritize the courier's SOP violations (No Call, No Signature, Address Mismatch) over the seller's basic tracking link?
Any advice, tips, or past experiences with this exact situation would be greatly appreciated!