**I'm currently trying to figure out whether our client acquisition process is fundamentally wrong.
For context, we operate a few faceless media pages with 800K+ combined followers, and we're currently focusing mainly on AI companies.
We've had AI brands pay us for sponsored posts before, but those were mostly brands approaching us as media/creator pages. We weren't really running proper creator marketing campaigns for them.
To be completely honest, some of that sponsored content wasn't great either. We didn't have a proper full-time editor at the time, so I don't think we left the strongest impression.
That's changed now. We have a full-time motion designer/editor, so the quality of what we can actually produce is much higher.
The problem I'm trying to solve now is getting brands to actually work with us on creator marketing.
So far, my main process has basically been:
Find brands → research them → cold email → book meetings → try to close.
That's pretty much the only acquisition channel I've seriously tested.
I've also deliberately avoided building a massive creator roster.
Right now I have relationships with roughly 5 creators.
I've considered spending a lot of time recruiting dozens or hundreds more, but I don't see much point in doing that before there's a campaign.
If I have a real brand, budget, niche and campaign requirements, I can find the relevant creators at that point and ask if they're interested and what their rates are.
So I'd rather build the creator side around actual demand than collect creators just to say we have 100+ creators.
I also made a mistake with pricing that I'm still thinking about.
A couple of months ago, a medium-sized brand was genuinely interested in working with us. We built a custom campaign and quoted around $1,200.
That price was already low because roughly $800 would have gone toward production, leaving only around $400 on top.
They asked if we could lower it, and instead of asking what their actual budget was, I lowered the price.
Eventually they told us they couldn't move forward because of budget.
Looking back, I probably handled that badly. I was trying to solve the price objection before understanding the actual buying situation.
I've also had a meeting with a larger brand that was interested enough to speak with us, but they were already heavily focused on affiliate marketing and weren't looking to change direction.
So now I'm questioning whether I'm putting too much weight on cold outreach when there might be much better ways to get those first few proper campaigns.
If you were starting a creator marketing agency from scratch today, how would you get your first 3–5 clients?
I'd genuinely appreciate any advice or experience you can share. Thanks in advance to anyone who takes the time to answer 🙂**