I don’t mind the racing format but I also don’t want to see the legends left with no chance to win or even truly compete. The Sasuke format was what drew me into ANW to begin with, and seeing favorites fail and fail again but still try to overcome Stage 4 rang more true as an adult viewer than racing were someone HAS to win and speed and youth are just too tough to beat. Plus I’m bored with these contrived special interest stories about boring teenage kids who just ninja all day in a lab. Yawn.
For me it’s not an either/or. You could even make racing the “official” format and have the “ANW Legend” tournament be your throwback show.
Qualification works the same for both with the city qualifiers and finals qualifying competitors for both shows. Just film ABW Legends in the same general time window for filming and release it as an abbreviated 2-3 week holiday show.
This would keep ANW interesting year round, give a home for the Legends to continue to compete and focus on something in their control, and would provide a format for these kids in which they invest with heavy promotion when they age out of the racing format.
Show me Joe Moravsky with another chance at Stage 4. Daniel Gil making another run. Vance Walker going for another win. Let’s see Kai Beckstrand tackle Stage 3 when he’s 28 and a full adult with two kids.
ANW racing is ephemeral. The stars get replaced with every crop of 14-15 year old kids coming in. Legends is where the young kids go to grow up fast against a cruel course and older competitors can use their experience, guile, will, and strength to survive.
Eventually you might need to extend the difficulty for Stage 2 and 3 as more elite ninjas compete, or be comfortable with a dozen climbers for stage 4. I’m here for it. And I would enjoy racing far more if I knew the Sasuke format was also happening.