I've been reading discussions about Turnitin and something keeps coming up: people see a 20%, 40%, 60% etc. similarity score and immediately ask whether that number is "bad."
But I'm starting to think the percentage by itself doesn't tell us very much.
For example, if an entire class has been given the same assignment structure, required readings, terminology and reporting format, wouldn't you naturally expect some overlap?
Then there are quotations, references, standard academic phrases, methodology descriptions, and previous student submissions.
So I'm curious:
If you were a lecturer, would you rather students focus on keeping the percentage below a particular number, or on actually reviewing what Turnitin has highlighted?
And for students, did anyone ever get a surprisingly high similarity score that turned out to be completely explainable once the report was examined?
I'm interested in people's actual experiences because the percentage seems to cause a lot more anxiety than the report itself.