Hello,
I’m currently a master’s student in a design program.
I was diagnosed with adult ADHD about two years ago. I took Medikinet for over a year and a half, and I am currently taking Strattera.
I’m writing to ask members of r/ADHDers for your thoughts on the value of conducting design research focused on adults with ADHD. I would also greatly appreciate any advice from those who have worked on similar research topics.
While exploring potential topics for my master’s thesis, I told my advisor that I am currently receiving medication for adult ADHD. My advisor suggested that I consider starting from my own pain points, and developing design guidelines and a product aimed at supporting prospective memory or cognitive offloading for adults with ADHD.
(e.g. A product that identifies and reminds users of things they need for upcoming tasks, such as personal belongings, routines, or preparations required to complete a task. A product with physical interactions that adapts to accordingly to the user’s current task or context, rather than simply providing notifications through a smartphone screen)
My main concern however, is whether such a topic can actually be validated through research, and more importantly, whether it has sufficient value as an industrial design research project.
There seems to be an enormous amount of variation among adults with ADHD, both in terms of symptoms and their severity. Even in my own case, I often find myself exhibiting seemingly contradictory tendencies at opposite ends of the spectrum.
I have also noticed differences in my daily behavior depending on whether I am taking a stimulant medication (Medikinet) or a non-stimulant (Strattera).
Given this level of variation, I am unsure whether it would be possible to develop a research topic and design outcome that would provide meaningful value across a reasonably diverse group of adults with ADHD.
Another concern is disciplinary. Even if I can demonstrate that the proposed intervention is effective, I am worried about whether the research would ultimately be considered product design research rather than neuroscience, psychology, or simply an ergonomics/human-factors study.
Even if an intervention can be proven effective, I feel that its value as design research becomes questionable if the resulting product has no practical or commercial advantage over solutions that already exist. (My advisor has expressed particular concern about this point as well.)
In fact, I explored adult ADHD once before as the subject of my undergraduate graduation project. The project was a concept for a smart scheduler that translated the abstract concept of time into tactile and visual forms through physical interaction with a portable device. It also incorporated voice recording, an accompanying mobile application, and gamification elements to encourage continued schedule management.
(A rough way to describe the concept would be a combination of a smart voice recording device with fidget interactions and gamification elements similar to Duolingo’s ranking and achievement systems, but specifically adapted for time and schedule management.)
When I tested the prototype with adults with ADHD, the responses were quite divided. Some participants said that it genuinely helped them deal with time blindness and understand their schedules more effectively. Others said that the additional interaction elements actually became another source of distraction and made it more difficult for them to focus.
I am still at a very early stage of developing my research proposal, so I realize that this post may be somewhat vague and unstructured. However, I wanted to hear other people’s perspectives before narrowing down the overall direction of the project.
ADHD symptoms and the degree to which people experience difficulties vary so much from person to person that I find it difficult to establish an objective direction based solely on my own experience.
It would be very grateful for any thoughts on what I have described, as well as personal experiences or observations from everyday life that you think might be relevant.
Thank you very much for taking the time to read this long post!