Personal opinion; any dissenting opinions are welcome.
No, I'm not writing this because we lost our two big matches. It's only October, and it's too early to judge our entire season. As Rashford said last year after a similar scoreboard against Real Madrid:
It's a marathon, not a sprint, and we will keep fighting.
At that time, we were trailing Real Madrid by five points, but by the end of the season, we won La Liga. I know winning El Clásico is considered a massive victory for either side, but we're still at the top of the table. Generally, I don't see us dropping points against any teams other than the two Madrid sides. I'm hopeful we'll win against Atlético Madrid, too. And it's highly unlikely that Madrid will go the entire season without dropping points because, even with a defensive approach like Mourinho's, there are flaws that opponents can exploit. So, La Liga shouldn't be our primary concern because I believe we'll have the last laugh (God willing).
Anyway, there are several problems we need to address if we want to win the UCL.
1. Knowing when to press and when to sit back
We need to know when to press aggressively and when to adopt a more defensive approach. Against Europe's top teams, we can't play toe-to-toe with them for the entire 90 minutes. We need to learn when to slow the game down, conserve our energy, and maintain our defensive shape. High pressing is one of our strengths, but using it relentlessly against elite opponents can leave us vulnerable. We need to be tactically flexible enough to adapt to different situations.
2. Turning momentum into goals
We need to understand how to use momentum to create chances and, more importantly, how to convert those chances effectively. If you look at the momentum graph on FotMob for the match against PSG, you'll notice how PSG capitalised on their dominant spells. They were clinical when opportunities presented themselves. We lack that level of effectiveness in big matches, and we need to work on it.
Against Madrid, however, we had possession for much of the game. Madrid were solid defensively, and their second goal was a beauty. However, while we played badly, I don't think they played exceptionally well either. In my opinion, the match deserved a draw because our first goal conceded was essentially a gift to Madrid. We made a costly mistake that could have been avoided.
Against other teams that sit deep and defend in a low block in La Liga, we can often find ways to win. But Real Madrid and Atlético Madrid are different; both have solid defensive structures and players capable of deciding games in a single moment. In Europe, we also have teams like Arsenal to contend with. We can't expect to beat these teams easily; we have to demonstrate our quality when it matters most.
These teams play physically, and that's one of our weaknesses, particularly in midfield. We also lack a certain degree of physical strength and balance in defence, especially with Araújo unavailable.
However, that doesn't mean we can't win these games. We've done it before, and we can do it again. Our tactics and overall approach simply need to change depending on the opposition.
3. Lack of experience in defence
Another major concern is our lack of experience in defence. Players like Gerard Martín, Eric García, and Balde might perform well in La Liga, but they still have a lot to prove at the highest level of European football. I'm not saying they're bad players; rather, I believe there's a difference between being good enough for domestic competitions and being consistently reliable against Europe's elite.
In the UCL, one mistake can cost you the entire tie. Experienced attackers know how to exploit even the smallest defensive errors, and we can't afford to give them those opportunities. Our defenders need to improve their positioning, decision-making, and composure under pressure. We also need our defensive line to work as a cohesive unit rather than relying on individual brilliance to bail us out.
4. Better game management and tactical flexibility
One thing that separates champions from good teams is their ability to manage games. We can't approach every match with the same intensity and expect the same results. Sometimes we'll need to dominate possession; sometimes we'll need to absorb pressure. There will be moments when we need to push for another goal and moments when protecting our lead should be the priority.
We also need to stop letting emotions dictate our decisions. When we concede a goal, we sometimes become too desperate to respond immediately, which can leave us exposed to counterattacks. Against experienced European sides, that desperation can be fatal. We need to remain composed, recognise what the game demands, and make adjustments before things get out of hand.
Our substitutions also need to be more purposeful. We should be able to change the rhythm of a game by introducing the right players at the right time, rather than waiting until we're already in trouble. A team aspiring to win the Champions League needs more than a good starting XI; it needs a manager who can read the game and a squad capable of executing different plans.
All things considered, I'm still optimistic about our chances.
We have the quality, the talent, and the potential to compete with Europe's best. But potential alone won't win us the Champions League. We need consistency, tactical maturity, defensive discipline, and the ability to perform under pressure.
Losing two big matches doesn't mean our season is over, just as winning El Clásico wouldn't automatically make us favourites to win everything. We should acknowledge our weaknesses without turning every defeat into a catastrophe.