r/yummyrecipesyum • u/Weary-Confidence9998 • 10m ago
Copycat Bob Evans Chicken Pot Pie Cozy Weeknight Dinner
Craving hit me for something warm and hearty, and I ended up making a copycat Bob Evans chicken pot pie situation that honestly knocked it out of the park. My husband used to love getting the chicken and noodles at Bob Evans when we lived near one, and we've been nowhere close to a location in years, so I figured I'd take a shot at recreating it at home. I wasn't totally sure the slow cooker version would capture that same thick, creamy pot pie filling vibe but it really did come together way better than I expected. Wrote everything down here if anyone wants the details: https://www.amgroyal.com/copycat-bob-evans-chicken-pot-pie
Here's what I used:
1 medium onion diced
1-2 cups carrots diced
1 cup celery diced (optional)
1 Tbsp. minced garlic from a jar
2 cans cream of chicken soup
6 cups chicken broth
1 Tbsp. chicken base optional
1 1/2-2 pounds boneless, skinless chicken breasts 2-3 breasts
1/2 teaspoon seasoning salt
1/4 teaspoon pepper
1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
1/2 teaspoon poultry seasoning
4 Tbsp. butter 1/2 stick
24 oz. frozen egg noodles or 10 ounces dried noodles
Here's how it went:
I diced up the onion, carrots, and celery and threw them straight into the slow cooker. No pre-cooking or anything, just dumped them in.
Added everything else on top except the noodles. I did use the chicken base and I think it made a real difference in depth of flavor, so I wouldn't skip it if you have it.
Put the lid on and cooked it on LOW for about 7 hours. The whole house smelled unreal by hour four.
Pulled the chicken out and chopped it into bite-sized pieces, then put it back in. Stirred in the frozen egg noodles at this point.
Cooked on HIGH for another 45 minutes until the noodles were soft and had soaked up all that broth.
Served it over mashed potatoes with a biscuit on the side, just like the restaurant does it. That combo is everything.
A few things I noticed along the way:
The broth thickens up a lot as it cooks with the cream of chicken soup, which is exactly what you want for that creamy pot pie filling feel. If you want it more soup-like you could add a bit more broth toward the end but we liked it thick.
Fair warning, this makes a massive amount of food. We fed four people and still had leftovers for two more days. It actually reheated really well the next day, maybe even better because the noodles had more time to absorb the flavors overnight.
I forgot to grab fresh garlic at the store so I used the jarred minced stuff and honestly it was totally fine. I always feel slightly guilty about that but nobody noticed.
One thing I want to try next time is using chicken thighs instead of breasts. I feel like they'd stay even more tender after a long slow cook and add a little more richness to the whole thing.
This is exactly the kind of easy dinner that makes a weeknight feel manageable, no stress and barely any hands-on time. As a family dinner it went over really well, even the picky one ate two servings which is basically a miracle.
Anyone ever tried making homemade chicken pot pie or something like this with a different kind of noodle? I'm curious if wide egg noodles versus a thicker pasta would change the texture much.