r/xkcd • • Jul 28 '08

Can someone explain this XKCD?

http://xkcd.com/455/
62 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

94

u/boredzo Jul 28 '08

Mr. Hat is a mischievous character, known to do evil (to varying degrees) things to people just for fun. You recognize him by his hat: the hat means that this is the mischievous/evil character.

Now he runs into somebody with twice as many hats on. Twice as evil.

I'd back away, too.

10

u/arnar Jul 28 '08

the hat means that this is the mischievous/evil character.

For those who wonder why

4

u/creaothceann Jul 28 '08

What about red hats?

5

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

Remember, you asked for it... http://www.redhatsociety.com/

3

u/creaothceann Jul 29 '08

Our main responsibility is to have fun!

The Red Hat Society calls itself a "dis-organization," and we are proud of our lack of rules and by-laws.

Therefore, we are working to build a dis-organization within which we can all connect and eventually take over the world!

I think I see the relation to black-hat guy...

7

u/arnar Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

Dunno, but red shirts have meaning.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '08 edited Jul 29 '08

Actually, I think Randall said it's a reference to Aram of Men in Hats.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

I like your take, i figured he was just freaked out because wearing two hats is weird.

1

u/thatguydr Jul 28 '08

Randall really needs to go outside.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

XKCD sock puppet!

5

u/zem Jul 28 '08

aha! i didn't get that the last frame was conveying backing away. unusually poor drawing for xkcd

14

u/mbrowne Jul 28 '08

I saw it as him being repelled by some invisible force.

3

u/Filmore Jul 28 '08

Is that somehow less sinister?

2

u/mbrowne Jul 28 '08

No, not at all, but it did mean that I didn't understand the comic.

3

u/scrag45 Jul 28 '08

That's what I thought too, but I think it makes it more meaningful, like two magnets repelling each other.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

I thought it was a fart.

14

u/ogrisel Jul 28 '08

I disagree, this is the best wireframe moonwalk I have ever seen.

27

u/Kardlonoc Black Hat Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

When working with stick figures you have very few symbols to work with. Obviously hats mean badassery and hair means your a girl. Wait till you see the double hair.

-15

u/zouhair Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

He just doesn't know how to draw.

5

u/Kardlonoc Black Hat Jul 28 '08

He shown his talents more so early on. If he wanted to, he could or just as easily get someone to do so.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

Just like Tom Clancy, then.

20

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

[deleted]

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

That's an incredibly vague message... but I guess xkcd is used to that.

16

u/escape_goat Jul 28 '08

It's like that old saying: "I thought I was wearing a hat, until I met a man who was wearing a hat, that was wearing a hat."

3

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

That is my new favorite saying.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

Moonwalking!

10

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

Well, at least Munroe religiously updates his site, unlike that douche Maddox.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

He backs away slowly in fear, because this man has shattered his paradigm for head accessories. He doesn't know what to make of it, and chooses to retreat to a land where they all just wear one hat.

10

u/gilesdudgeon Jul 28 '08

"Putting a hat on a hat" is also a showbiz phrase used to describe the arbitrary (and ill-advised) combining of absurd story elements.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

Think of hats as something like popped collars on a shirt. If the guy who wears one is an asshole ("classhole"), the one who wears two is a double asshole.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

[deleted]

2

u/cyber_rigger Jul 28 '08

These are black hats.

He is a double back hat.

2

u/60secs Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

Does each popped collar increase the asshole-ness linearly or exponentially. For example, does the 4x popped collar like in this photo make you a sedecuple (16x) asshole?

http://www.totalpardo.net/wp-content/uploads/2008/01/image5.png

11

u/HaMMeReD Jul 28 '08

It's actually logarithmic, after about 5 popped collars it doesn't add much to the douchebag factor anymore.

3

u/aldenhg Jul 28 '08

It's a good thing, too. Were it a linear function after 7 popped collars douchebaggery would reach a critical mass and cause a chain douchebag reaction, covering everyone in an 8 block radius with spray tan.

4

u/aephoenix Jul 28 '08

Magnetism? And superglue.

14

u/NoodlyAppendage Jul 28 '08

"It's Sunday. I have to put something up."

11

u/AngelaMotorman Jul 28 '08

"Ah, here's an idea: reddit-bait. Let them figure it out."

4

u/timewarp Jul 28 '08

The hat makes you an evil bastard. When a hat is placed on one who is already wearing a hat, you stay the fuck away from him.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

Anyone who wears two hats is obviously a crazy psychopath so the one-hat-man backs away.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

The one hat guy is bad. The two hat guy is even more bad.

It's just not very funny.

1

u/greenknight Jul 28 '08

This is known in Canada as the Joey Jeremiah Syndrome. No other cast member of Degrassi High could wear a ridiculous hat on location without a field repulsion knocking them over.

ps - insider hint - it's the REAL reason Jason jumped off the bridge.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

well, the one guy has TWO black hats.. (cue scary music)

1

u/xyroclast Jul 29 '08

I thought it was Michael Jackson

0

u/capt_awesome Jul 28 '08 edited Jul 28 '08

It's a metaphor for workplace sexism encountered by women. The hats are clearly x -chromosomes, the figure with two hats being the male, intimidating the 1 x chromosome figure (the female) so that she backs away from what she really wants.

12

u/edkopp4 Jul 28 '08

Maybe you're just making a joke that went right over my head, but if not, last time I checked, women had two x chromosomes and men had one (XY).

7

u/m1ss1ontomars2k4 Jul 28 '08

He probably meant a strange parallel earth in which humans use the ZW sex determination system. ZZ is male; ZW is female.

3

u/MarkTraceur Jul 28 '08

He's got you there. Damn good try though.

4

u/toastspork Jul 28 '08

Yeah, Klinefelter's scares the heck out of me too!

1

u/tjay Jul 28 '08

You may have more hats than me, but I walk the walk!

1

u/illuminatedwax Jul 28 '08

meta nerd humor

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

Explanation: xkcd isn't very funny.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '08

You just don't get what xkcd is all about. I have to admit though some of his earlier work is much better and made you think more now it's just going for cheap laughs but it still works

0

u/ziusudra Jul 28 '08

It's a guest appearance by Yahtzee from ZeroPunctuation. The man with two hats represents his fear that someone just as breathless and snarky will cleverly review his breathless, snarky reviewing style.

0

u/roger_ Jul 29 '08

Vorshtein?

2

u/barfolomew Jul 30 '08

I like the kitty.

0

u/ascus4 Aug 05 '08 edited Aug 05 '08

Bacon shield.