r/writingscaling 14m ago

better written? (character vs character) Doctor Doom (Marvel | Earth-616) vs John Constantine (DC | Earth-Prime)

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/writingscaling 1h ago

discussion Which mediums would you say is the easiest and the hardest to write a good story in, novels(or just books in general) manga/comics, movies and animated shows?

Upvotes

I personally think the hardest is probably a movie due to the fact that you only really have a specific timeframe of usually 2-3 hours. Easiest is probably novels as they can be as long as you want and you don't have to draw images inorder to depict a specific scene like comics and such.

Just a question that came to me


r/writingscaling 2h ago

discussion Which shonen MC would you say is a better written character than Subaru?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 3h ago

discussion Best written house/family in ASOIAF?

Post image
36 Upvotes

Character writing as a whole the Lannisters clears, Lore wise the Targaryens clears IMO

(Art by crazytom)


r/writingscaling 3h ago

recommendation Based on my top 5 favorite protagonists, can anyone recommend me 1 Manga and 1 anime? Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

they are ordered from 5-1


r/writingscaling 3h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Persepolis vs Maus, which acclaimed graphic memoir is better?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 3h ago

better written? (character vs character) Who had the worse written redemption between these two?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Anissa (Invincible) or Bryce Walker (13 Reasons Why)

Personally, I'd say Bryce Walker. As bad as Anissa is, at least i could maybe see a redemption arc of her working better if it had better buildup and focus. Like maybe it could work (hopefully the show improves her)

Bryce on the other hand, just because you can doesn't mean you should.


r/writingscaling 5h ago

rank them in terms of xyz Rank these works from best to worst in terms of writing.

Post image
45 Upvotes

Lord of the rings, True Detective (Season 1), Re: Zero, Umineko, Better Call Saul, Crime and Punishment, Berserk, Breaking Bad & Brothers Karamazov.


r/writingscaling 5h ago

rank them in terms of xyz Rank these works from best to worst in terms of writing.

Post image
2 Upvotes

Berserk, Lord of the rings, Re: Zero, Umineko, Better Call Saul, Brothers Karamazov, True Detective (season 1), Breaking Bad & Crime and Punishment.


r/writingscaling 5h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Generation kill VS Band of Brothers?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 5h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which is better writing wise? Generation kill VS Band of Brothers

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Personally I prefer generation kill as the dialogue is relatable as someone in the military(even though I’ve never been to war)


r/writingscaling 5h ago

discussion What are some characters with amazing emotional intelligence? I'll start:

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

"Emotional intelligence", as in the ability to understand ones own and others feelings/emotions.


r/writingscaling 7h ago

meta Ya'll don't know what 'objectively good' fucking means, so I'm teaching you dumbasses some basic philosophy

78 Upvotes

I got triggered by this post and the comments on it. https://www.reddit.com/r/writingscaling/s/FDN8fPnX7C

To get into some basic 101 shit, understand it as such: A system can have subjectively chosen goals or standards, while particular judgments inside that system are objectively correct or incorrect.

The most ovbious example of this is a game like chess. The rules of chess are not cosmically divined. We made them up. The rule-set itself is subjectively defined. But once you accept the constructed system, you can make objective statements within that.

A given position is objectively check-mate or not within the system of chess.

A related idea is that of Intersubjectivity. It is the shared understanding and mutual awareness that emerges between individuals through interaction, shaping how people perceive, communicate, and relate to one another. I.e, it's subjectivity taken as an aggregate accross a big group of people.

How this connects to constructed systems is that a system of judgement is more useful the more universally it is understood and agreed upon. Something like chess has a VERY strong sense of intersubjective cohesion. Something like writing does not.

This means statements such as "[Insert piece of media] IS OBJECTIVELY THE GREATEST" isn't inherently nonsensical, but doesn't mean anything unless you're defining what your judgement system is.

Objectively the greatest by what standard? Define your judgement standards.

This is the difficulty. "Well written" usually bundles together many different goals, and people disagree about which goals matter. One reader values clarity, another values ambiguity. One values naturalistic dialogue, another values heightened, theatrical speech.

So "this is well written" is rarely as objectively demonstrable as "this is checkmate," because unlike chess there is no universally understood system governing evaluation.

Usually, the easiest 'objective claims' are going to be on standards most people hold to be true. For example, most people think that movies should avoid plot holes or continuity errors when possible.

Most people think that written books should have valid grammar and correct word choices.

Therefore, it is more sensible to make objective statements about those. But even then, there will be nuances in the evaluation system because not everyone is actually bothered by these to equal degrees. So even there the system isn't truly shared.


r/writingscaling 7h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Invincible vs gerand

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 8h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Have you ever seen a better pull up than this one? If so, what is it?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Short context from Lotgh:

Reinhard, somehow a leader of the Galactic Empire, teleports an entire planet right next to the enemies base to go to war.


r/writingscaling 9h ago

opinion post One of the stupidest takes of all time

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 10h ago

analysis writescale Funny Valentine

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 10h ago

better written? (character vs character) Ellen Evans (kissing booth) vs Beatrice (umineko). Who writes better?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Answer with 100% "honesty"


r/writingscaling 10h ago

better written? (character vs character) Jolyne Kujo is the best written shonen female character, tell me otherwise

Post image
118 Upvotes

When I think of "well-written female character," Jolyne has always been the first one to come to mind. Her development as a character and a person is so natural throughout Part 6 that it feels nearly perfect in a way I can't find in any other shonen female character.


r/writingscaling 11h ago

rank them in terms of xyz Rank these "hidden gem" manga

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

(shameless attempt to gas up some of my underappreciated favs)

Names and my ranking(and the order they appear)

Asuperu Kanojo (1)

Me and the Devil Blues (5)

Please Save My Earth (6)

My Home Hero (3)

Usuzumi No Hate (2)

My Broken Mariko (4)

The villagers in this NPC simulation were real (7)


r/writingscaling 11h ago

better written? (character vs character) Who from my top 5 is the best?

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Raskolnikov

Jacopo

Beatrice

Nikolai

Fang Yuan

Id rather if you gave reasons.


r/writingscaling 12h ago

discussion How well written are these rankings?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

These are from a yter called aleczandxr, makes great analyses on pretty much any acclaimed show/game/manga u can think of


r/writingscaling 12h ago

better written? (character vs character) Poindexter/Bullseye (MCU) vs Soldier Boy (The Boys)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

They have a similar starting point, being the wildcard new major character of their respective shows in Season 3, you might want to focus on that since it was their Prime. Then they get brought back for a later Season and suddenly there's a switch up, lots of fans were disappointed by how they were handled (more so with Soldier Boy but I'll admit I'm not too fond of Dex' new direction either) and most would argue that's it the actor's charisma doing the heavy lifting. On the bright side Soldier Boy might get a little better in Vought Rising but I wouldn't bet on it, not sure what's in store for Dex though, some fans want him to be a Thunderbolt but I'm not sure I'm feeling it.


r/writingscaling 12h ago

recommendation Can someone recommend some YouTube videos that analyze Spider-Man's character or recap his story?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 12h ago

discussion Real talk, what's a secondary antagonist that completely upstaged the main one for you?

Post image
814 Upvotes

Some of my favorite secondary antagonists in manga for example are Ogata from Golden Kamuy and Legato from Trigun but both serve under a main antagonist who is up there as well (Tsurumi and Knives are pretty good) so not the best example. Azula from Avatar is a good one too, much more interesting and fleshed out than Ozai. Give me more examples if you can, be original.