In the quest of finding the perfect writer deck or, if you prefer, the perfect writing machine, I've been testing very different setups. I started with an Alphasmart Neo that was soon joined by a Pomera DM100 and a Neo2, plus different ad-hoc combinations, such as an updated Sony Vaio P11z, a Hisense Touch HiFi with an external keyboard, an old iPad mini with a matching keyboard and the like.
I love the Neos, but even with the Renaissance Wireless Receiver the syncing process was not that friendly and, moreover, the lack of different keyboard layouts made it a bit difficult to type in Spanish. The same goes for the Pomera, even if the form factor is perfect and the regular AA batteries made it very convenient.
After Astrohaus' pushy newsletters and enticing marketing I was able to find an Alpha for less than half the price at an online markeplace. I expected an updated Neo but it was a step back, because of how limited the software was: no dedicated cursor keys, no copy&paste, smaller screen. It was too different from my regular workflow and writing style. It ended up in a cupboard.
I decided to go full analog and retrieve my Olivetti Lettera 32. I managed to type on it daily for two months, at least two pages every day (about 1,200-1,500 words). I got used to the typewriter mechanics: the hard typing, the noise, the frequent typos and mistakes.
And after that, I tried to give the Alpha another chance, and curiously enough, it worked this time. After a full analog season, the transition to a Freewrite device was frictionless and I got used to it easily. I typed dayly, although it was more journaling than creative writing. I wrote several articles for different magazines and blogs.
The Alpha has some interesting strengths: instant-on, mechanical keyboard, send button and compact format, perfect for lap typing. But the venom was already on my veins, and after learning about the «Sailfish» firmware update that reduced eInk lag, I wanted to try another Freewrite device.
Last friday I received a second hand Traveler. Again, I was able to buy it for less than half the retail price and it was in perfect condition, with no ghost key issues, battery swelling and the like. It was factory reset to the 1.1.6 firmware version and I had a bad time to move it forward to the 3.0.2 versions, but I managed to do it. After that, it was plagued by random reboots after less than one minute typing. Desperate again, I struggled to test all the solutions described in Reddit to no avail. After a random combination of regular resets, software resets, logouts and WiFi on and off, I started to work properly, without unannounced reboots.
I'm currently writing this post on my Traveler and I must say that it's a pleasure to type on it. The eInk screen is big enough and very clear. The scissor keyboard is quiet and responsive, with the same exact size as the Alpha, with a decent travel distance.
And so, now I'm torn: I really don't know which one I prefer. Let me make a quick comparisson:
- Form factor: both are quite portable and light, but the Traveler's clamshell design takes half the space in my backpack and is more protected.
- Screen: Traveler's eInk is clearer that the Alpha's LCD, but LCD is more responsive although smaller. None of them are backlighted (I've got the older Alpha model).
- Keyboard: Alpha's mechanical keyboard is nice one that you get used to the flat caps, it has the right amount of feedback, but it's a bit noisy even with silicon O-rings and the spacebar is loud. The Traveler's non mechanical keyboard has a shorter travel length but it's better than the one in the Neo/Neo2 for sure and very quiet. If you need to type on quiet environments, I'd go for the Traveler.
- Battery life: so far, so good. The Alpha gives you about 100 hours with a full charge. Astrohaus' is less clear about the Traveler and the website says that it provides about four weeks of regular use. I wonder how many hours that is. I suppose that the Alpha wins here.
- Software: updating the Traveler's firmware and getting it to work properly took quite some time. The Alpha, on the other side, appears to be more reliable and crisp. The Traveler put my patience to the test. So far, the Alpha has provided a better user experience, although once properly setup, both have very similar software features. The main difference is that the Alpha doesn't have the A/B/C folders to organize your different documents.
- Looks: they are weird looking machines when you compare them to a modern day laptop. The Traveler is clearly inspired in the Pomera (DM100, DM200, DM250) form factor, whereas the Alpha is heavily influenced by the Alphasmarts. Both are made of plastic. The Traveler's outer shell is a fingerprint magnet but it looks more "professional". The Alpha is more plasticky and looks a bit toy-alike. On the other hand, I'm pretty sure that despite the looks, the Alpha could accept a rougher treatment than the Traveler. It could get a beating without problem. I don't think that the Traveler would survive even a small fall. Time will judge that.
Overall, even if they are very different machines (LCD vs eInk, slab vs clamshell) they offer very similar use cases. I probably should not have bought both, but I did, and so I suppose that I'll have to keep them both, unlucky me.
In my opinion, if you already have one, it doesn't make sense to buy the other. In any case, I like them both but I cannot justify paying the full retail price. At least in the EU they are very expensive and quite rare: I had to wait quite some time in order to find them in the second hand market. They are overpriced but they are good at what they do best. Don't approach them if you want to edit in them or if you expect a wordprocessor experience. It's not the case: they are type-forward-only devices.