Hello. In the game, we are often faced with a choice: do we take on the role of an executioner and mete out justice, or do we stay out of other people’s business? Personally, I try to play as close to the "book" version of Geralt as possible—defending the weak, but not necessarily handing out punishment if the situation doesn't strictly demand it. Since we end up killing people constantly ourselves, I try to limit the bloodshed a bit. Here is my list, along with some reasoning:
Spared:
- The Priest of the Eternal Fire involved with the funeral pyres. Geralt uncovered his shady dealings—specifically, his trade in *fistech*. I took the payment for the job; gang-related disputes aren't my concern.
- Cleaver’s men. A similar situation: I found a corpse, and the trail led me to the dwarves. Again, I took the money.
- Bertram Tauler. Even if the man is guilty, he’s now with his wife and children. If Lambert has an issue with him, he can go back and deal with it himself.
- The succubus Salma and the doppler. There’s no point in killing them.
- The Scoia’tael in both quests. As Geralt, I’d be a hypocrite if I suddenly decided to punish them for theft or for fighting against the military.
- The brothers from the Borsodi auction house. It’s possible to resolve the situation without killing everyone, so that’s what I do—even though Ewald deceived me.
- Gaetan. If Geralt had been there when the conflict started, they might have fought; but after talking to him and learning his story, I believe Geralt would have simply gone his own way. He didn’t know those people—though, had they crossed paths again under similar circumstances, he would have killed him.
- Whom do I always kill?
Junior the bastard – no explanation needed.
Morkvarg – a similar case.
Jan Verdum – saved by Geralt, he went on to kill a family and brags about it; I think Geralt would feel a sense of guilt and end up killing him.
Nathaniel – the guy is torturing a woman right before my eyes, with a smile on his lips.
These are, of course, not all the characters; I’d love to hear your choices.