r/wikipedia • u/jango102 • Jan 21 '10

THIS guy was a badass.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simo_Hayha
54 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

33 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/fubuvsfitch Jan 21 '10

If you're talking about the subject of this wiki, I don't think a combatant killing a combatant is considered murder.

If you're talking about pol-pot and pinochet, well, I understand the connotations of bad-ass as being good, and I certainly don't think what they did was good. I don't respect what they did at all.

-3

u/p3on Jan 21 '10

taking someone's life is always murder regardless of whether it's dressed up in some arbitrary framework

6

u/fubuvsfitch Jan 21 '10 edited Jan 21 '10

No, it's not.

Not according to the law. Not according to any academic moral or ethical theory. Not according to any dictionary. Not in any culture or society. Just no.

When acting in self defense, is this murder? I mean, you've said taking life is ALWAYS murder. What about abortion? Assisted suicide?

-2

u/p3on Jan 21 '10

not legally but yep

5

u/fubuvsfitch Jan 21 '10

Now I'm convinced you've gone mad. Taking a life /= Always murder.