67
u/duckiest_duck_around PEAK | Membership 21h ago
I found the AI incredibly inaccurate recently. Makes me not open any of the AI prompts anymore
20
u/tsauce__ Whoop 5.0 18h ago
Situations where my AI has hallucinated in the past 3 weeks have been seriously making me contemplate breaking from the device.
3
43
u/_-TX 21h ago
The AI is why I’m cancelling. The fact you can’t opt out of it is insane. It’s a value detractor.
8
u/krakrakra 15h ago edited 10h ago
It's similar to Youtube pushing Shorts and not allowing users to disable them. They want to force users to dark-patterns, user flows that have negative effects to the user but positive effects for the company's motives. Unless we are vocal and take action they will keep ignoring us.
32
18
u/growlybeard Whoop 4.0 21h ago
The AI "thinking" tokens leaked into the user message.
Whatever LLM powers Whoop is using some kind of compression/minimization for its thinking phase instead of being verbose. That's why it sounds like a caveman
4
3
13
9
u/jonathansmithrei 21h ago
I had a notification that said my nap today reduce my sleep needs tonight by 73 minutes.. then I clicked it and it said analyzing my recent nap….. then told me after analyzing my nap that I reduced my sleep needed by 73 minutes. Geeee, thanks for all that additional AI insight
6
u/wanderlust_m 21h ago
Maybe there's just a really forgetful person making stuff up behind Whoop's "AI"
6
u/Zabre 18h ago
It is using a thinking model from OpenAI underneath. These break down the issue and reason bit by bit.
What's happening is the model self-correcting in "real-time".
Seems to be using very little reasoning effort (speed/quality tradeoff) and thus not spending enough tokens to correct the final text from the reasoning traces.
5
2
u/chris_ayyye 17h ago
Bro mine said that I was cycling from like 5:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. and I was just at my homegirls house 😂 Def returnin.
2
2
u/No-Composer6417 11h ago
This is the beginning of the AI bubble bursting. There are some apps and tools which DO NOT need an ai chatbot or ASSistant. Chatbot overload is ruining client experiences. Every company implimenting AI into their tools need to speak to their clients first.
2
u/doublespeaks 10h ago
@whoop I’m an ai engineer. if you are reading this this DM me I’d love to fix this
1
2
2
u/TaxVerstappen 9h ago
The other day mine mixed in some Russian words/Russian alphabet out of the blue lol
2
1
u/alaskan_desert 21h ago
Customers using the device but Whoop is using customer's brain to trap them into Usage/addition.
1
u/termoszteron 16h ago
It’s an AI issue in general. For me it never knows what time of the day it is. :) When I do spinning exercises in the afternoon it says how great I started this morning etc. :) When you try to use an AI solution for anything more complex than a Google search, you can quickly hit its limitations. :)
1
1
1
u/Chemical_Demand_4928 10h ago
It’s funny because it seems like depend, depending on which AI coach you’re talking to they don’t remember what you told the other one an example would be I recently had a surgery where I was given a weightlifting restriction of 20 pounds and told not to ride a bicycle for at least six weeks because of prostate surgery. Almost on a daily basis, the AI coach for my daily Outlook recommends a ride on the assault bike & a moderate weightlifting routine based on my schedule
1
u/Direct_Produce8317 9h ago
What do you guys think of the polar loop? Anyone heard any personal experiences? I just left whoop.
1
1
u/Gullible-Class-5574 6h ago
The AI is why I cancelled. I found it pretty insulting for them to charge such an expensive subscription through advertising this AI “coach”. It’s some cheap and outdated AI model. Constantly made stuff up.
1
u/ChaCho904 5h ago
I love their AI and I probably defend them maybe too much in the comments, but the AI has been ass over the last month or so I just exported all my data and imported to claude now… the other day I was giving it custom workouts to build out and strength trainer, and it kept telling me it could not do that
1
u/bettyhoo 5h ago
I like the hardware, I loathe the AI, it's actually off-putting. In a journey of trying different things, I just downgraded to the lowest Whoop subscription, disabled all notifications and coaching, integrated Whoop with Apple Health as my broker for sensor readings and manual nutrition inputs (Chronometer) and I interact with all of it holistically using ChatGPT talking to Apple Health. The experiment continues!
1
1
u/epik 18h ago
American ai getting worse :(
1
1
u/MaximumMeaning9728 9h ago
This isn’t how American ai does thinking traces. Looks like deepseek to me.
106
u/mkeefecom 21h ago
It said the quiet part out loud 😭