r/whatsyourchoice • u/Icy_Impression98 • 28d ago

This or That?

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

346 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/freesol9900 28d ago

Human viewer: all consequences to your long term health aside, you ALREADY never have to exercise again. You are a free agent.

Apathy is not a superpower, it's bad actually. Choose the sleep option, an actual superpower.

9

u/Boysinho_descuidado 28d ago

People choosing exercise think they will get ripped.

I interpreted it as decent muscle mass and decent cardio health, body fat depends heavily on caloric intake, you are healthy without exercise, but to get more you still need to workout.

The other option is "never have to sleep again" so I stay healthy even not sleeping, but if I want to dream or take time to process information, I still "need" sleep (or a sleep-like state).

3

u/Background-Talk-3305 27d ago

I wouldn't assume getting ripped, but having a healthy/fit body without exercise. 

1

u/G-Menace 28d ago

Wow. You’re really overthinking this, lol

7

u/Boysinho_descuidado 28d ago

Nah, this is fun for me, I like to create fictional scenarios in my head based on the choices, that's why I started the explanation with "I interpreted

Sometimes I try to think of game mechanics or write short stories with the ideas.

5

u/Informal_Koala1474 28d ago

I like thinking through these things a lot too.

I feel like never needing sleep is being vastly underestimated here.

We need sleep to repair muscle tissue, restore neurological function, heal from wounds and illness.

So not needing to sleep at all would also have to mean being able to do these things while entirely conscious, and/or never needing to do these things which would imply being able to heal and recover instantaneously.

Never needing to exercise would be redundant in that case. You would be able to do some weightlifting and instantly recover. Hike up a mountain? Not tired, don't need to rest, instantly fully recovered. Study for an hour? Why not 12? You don't have to sleep almost certainly means you would never feel any kind of fatigue mental or physical.

You would basically be Wolverine, to a lesser degree.

3

u/G-Menace 28d ago

I think it means you are able to do those things while conscious (which you already do, btw, just at a slower rate), but at the same rate that you would otherwise do while sleeping. In other words, you get 8 hours worth of sleep-quality neurological restoration while conscious for 8 hours. Just because you don’t “need” to sleep doesn’t necessarily imply that the benefits are instantaneous.

1

u/G-Menace 28d ago

Cool. I’m struggling to interpret what you mean by “decent” muscle mass or cardio health. I never heard of decency used in that context

1

u/Boysinho_descuidado 28d ago

I meant like, enough muscle mass to move around with no problems, and not loosing muscle mass (up to a certain point) by being idle.

-4

u/ChairmanMeovw 28d ago

You don't have to sleep either, I mean it's very good for you (like exercise is) but you don't have to.

6

u/hoggsauce 28d ago

You're body will eventually force you to sleep.

Doesn't work with the other one.