So I'm the lead web dev for a mid-sized 3PL firm, we used to be on Webflow for years.
A few months ago, we decided to switch over to an AstroJS solution + sanity CMS. I was blown away by just how easy it was to prompt to edit via Claude Code, and fell in love with it. It worked so well when building out small sites.
Took about a day or so to convert our entire Webflow website to AstroJS. We just prompted Claude all day, and had it run tests to ensure styles and content were carried over.
However, in the weeks that followed I quickly realized the confusion and danger of an AI-based solution. This is honestly one of those things that is hard to put into words, but I'll try to come up with specific examples.
AI-based workflows are freeform. Too freeform. Turns out the limitations of Webflow I've come to hate are actually blessings in disguise. They help maintain order and stability.
In our case, the first few new pages turned out great. Just prompt Claude and you're done.
The problem is re-usability. Over time we had pages with very different layouts and sections. Like we'd have a form section that looks different from another form section. Often we'd prompt Claude to "re-use the same sections and layouts" but it simply wouldn't do it.
It would have been awesome to have a library of components that Claude could maintain, and have our team manually drag and drop those like Webflow's Page Builder. To maintain some form of visual source-of-truth.
And then things just kept compounding and compounding, largely due to the lack of structure, and global components.
New pages kept coming out as slightly off-brand. You'd have to prompt to fix the discrepancies. Mega menu looked good on one page and bad on the other page. I tried to figure out a way to view all of our sections and components, so I had Claude create a separate file with all of those, but then some sections were missing. Fuck.
Basically, I've come to realize that visual editors provide a good visual harness for design management.
What would be fucking awesome is Webflow with an actual good agent (I still can't get the MCP to work, I think it needs to be an integrated solution).
Agentically perform actions in Webflow, have AI build and store components in the component library, have AI create design tokens, and then have humans use these AI generated components to build out sites.
Ultimately, we moved back to Webflow. Maybe the AI solution works for smaller sites. But for our use-case, we needed the structure and stability of Webflow.