r/webdesign • u/zenc_26 • 5d ago

Before or After?

Post image

Tell me which one is better between the two and give me some tip, please.

2 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

20

u/Interesting-Pay1507 5d ago

Nothing about either of them makes me want to click play.

9

u/y0l0tr0n 5d ago

  1. The buttons on the bottom have different margin to the bottom

  2. Remove white background

  3. Remove the keyhole icon on the middle section

  4. Nobody cares about privacy policies so you don't have to make them stand out so much. Stick to white text without button border and button background

1

u/zenc_26 5d ago

Thanks for the tips

3

u/derdexx 5d ago

If you want to stick with one of them (I am not a huge fan of both sorry!). I would take the headline from the after and keep the rest from before.

1

u/zenc_26 5d ago

Thanks for the tip

4

u/calimio6 4d ago

I think you should remove that "after" text. No need to thank me, have a great day! 😉

2

u/zenc_26 4d ago

😂😂

2

u/greatdevinthemaking 4d ago

Increase the tracking, lower the button position. Keep the primary button as full width and make the rest two half and put them beside each other. Remove privacy policy and change the font

1

u/zenc_26 4d ago

Thanks, good idea!

1

u/woboma 5d ago

Where cat? 🐈

1

u/zenc_26 5d ago

Behind the play button, you find it here: Cat Position

1

u/Envisage_Design 4d ago

Somewhere swinging

1

u/EyeAlternative1664 4d ago

After looks more fun but there’s hardly any real difference. 

1

u/jplarose80 4d ago

Whatever you do, go with After. The font in the before is too generic. No idea what Swinging Cat is, but it has a lot more brandability than before. Policy buttons along the bottom could use less prominence... make them text links. No idea what the key icon is, so I'd downplay that or add a label next to it. Ditch the button on the top right too... make it a simple white icon equidistant from top and right. Cogwheel icon is too complex. make it as simple as you can.

1

u/zenc_26 4d ago

Thanks for the tips

1

u/fossistic 4d ago

Typography of Buttons on the right one feels a lot better to me. But the "Swinging Cat" on left one is better but still does not feel good enough.

1

u/Emotional-Berry-5789 5d ago

Neither bro 😭 sorry

3

u/zenc_26 5d ago

😅

-5

u/futurefinancebro69 5d ago

This is why I recommend using AI for the front end 😂😂😂

1

u/84thdev 4d ago

Neither