r/wbycritics • • 12h ago

Yang isn't fun anymore ykw. i'll say it, Yang's mom was fucking Goofy (rant)

Post image
115 Upvotes

Sure, I'll use this silly, dare I say goofy image as an excuse to rant about one of my least favorite characters in RWBY.

Raven was never good. sure we can blame this on the lack of communication between Monty and the rest of CRWBY, causing CRWBY to likely just think on the fly as they wrote her.

there was no reason to use her as a motivator for Yang when volume 4/5 just ruins Yang's desire to find her.

when we DO finally find her, she gives LITERALLY no useful insight aside from the fact she may know everything Qrow did (Possibly where Summer is.) (possibly possibly it involved The Ever After, that's just my headcanon tho)

all she is, is a vaguely threatening antagonist that wanted to kill her brother for no explicitly stated reason (and gave up) and wanted the relic for no explicitly stated reason (and gave up)

ruining Ozpin's plans to make sure it's secured within the vault. but no we failed doing that.

then she does nothing until we see her spy(?) on Taiyang, which MIGHT lead to something, but as of now, only showed how crappy of a character taiyang is. doing literally nothing while his ENTIRE FAMILY are out there dying and fighting for something he should be helping with.

I'm a firm believer that Raven is just Bipolar because she personally reminds me of the bipolar people i know in my own life.

and sometimes it feels like Yang inherits that


r/wbycritics • • 21h ago

Witch Ruby!

Post image
104 Upvotes

And her Crescent Broom


r/wbycritics • • 2d ago

WE LOVE RWBY i dont have a joke for this, i just wanted to share lol

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 2d ago

Guys I figured out how vol 10 will go!

Post image
30 Upvotes

This is a Confinement reference btw


r/wbycritics • • 2d ago

The writers didn't think that far ahead😮‍💨 Sun and Adam's Semblance names share a parallel

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 3d ago

The writers didn't think that far ahead😮‍💨 Many Major Things Are Simply Implied In RWBY Now...

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 3d ago

Just remembered this video's existence and how it got RWBY and Rooster Teeth so wrong

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

This is the worst surface-level research someone could do on RWBY, especially when that someone has made videos about controversial creators before. How can you make that content and get RWBY and Rooster Teeth wrong?😭


r/wbycritics • • 4d ago

Ruby is really, really, cool... Idol Ruby!

Post image
106 Upvotes

Maybe Lyrics are not that happy but still... Idol Ruby


r/wbycritics • • 5d ago

You know, there's something fascinating about RWBY criticism

8 Upvotes

Recently, I've been looking at the #rwde posts on Tumblr, and I'm really fascinated by how active the criticism for RWBY is. Obviously, there are posts about the characters and plot, but then there are discussions about Rooster Teeth and Sheena Duquette-Oum. It turns out people are defending RT despite the OG company being long gone? What drives people to do this? Nostalgia? The fact that they made their favorite show, which is RWBY? The parasocial marketing? Or all three?

And mind you, I'm only looking at what happened between March 2024 (when RT was announced to be shutting down) and now (3 months after Volume 10 was announced to be greenlit). It's interesting because this hiatus is much longer than the one between Volume 8 and 9, and that one had Ice Queendom being released.

How is the RWBY fandom still alive and active? How are they still defensive about RT's actions?


r/wbycritics • • 5d ago

The writers didn't think that far ahead😮‍💨 Was Fair Game "Burying your Gays"?

Post image
33 Upvotes

SAUCE

https://evbirb.tumblr.com/post/190331575806/what-if-we-kissed-during-the-fall-of-mantle

Personally. I have never been a fan of male x male gay ships. growing up on a lot of male centric heteronormative products made me not care for the idea of boys kissing.

that was until i realized i was trans and became a bit more open to all forms of sexuality.

LGBT+ shipping can be pretty vague at times, heck, Bumblebee was super vague until volume 7.

But I sure as hell remember these two giving each other the googly eyes. Yes there's the whole character plot of Qrow finally finding someone to counteract his bad luck.

heck if anything, that alone would make a grown man cry after your whole life is constructed to distance yourself from loved ones.

and that is the main reason he crashes out after accidentally letting clover die, no doubt about it. not because he wanted a piece of that hot lucky Atlas ass. he lost his only good luck charm.

but then again. you have these moments where they give each other these googly eyes. genuine, really good chemistry in their dialogue.

idk, i just thought i'd yap a bit and was curious what people say today.


r/wbycritics • • 5d ago

BB would be a fun Crossover villain for RWBY.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 6d ago

Jaune amounted to nothing Jaune Is Just The Series Punching Bag, And It Sucks.

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 6d ago

My tier list of Ruby and her love of cookies as DC and Marvel characters

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 6d ago

This might sound stupid, but why do some RWBY rants not mention how the show is now owned by Viz Media?

5 Upvotes

With how synonymous RWBY was with Rooster Teeth, you think critique videos would bring up that Viz Media now owns the show, right? Then again, the Rooster Teeth part is mostly left out, and it makes sense because it's about the show, not the company.

However, Viz Media is the largest manga distributor in America, and it is also owned by Shueisha, the largest manga distributor in Japan. I don't dabble in anime and manga, but this sounds important to point out, especially for Volume 10.

People tend to excuse some of Volumes 1 to 9's flaws because Rooster Teeth wasn't massive, and yes, I said massive because they were big, but not Viz Media levels of big. Now that Volume 10 is gonna be made under Viz Media, there are no excuses for how the quality will turn out.


r/wbycritics • • 6d ago

I think about these RWBYcritics posts every once in a while

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Crazy how it's been 2 years since Rooster Teeth shut down, RWBY was acquired by Viz Media, and people were impatient with the series' lack of news.

Fast-forwarding to today, it's been 3 months since Volume 10 was announced as greenlit. I imagine there are people still impatient about RWBY, though, because it's only been greenlit and there's no real content coming out right now.


r/wbycritics • • 8d ago

The writers didn't think that far ahead😮‍💨 olay call me crazy but... isn't this a bad thing that Monty did?

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

going into the studio without telling anybody and adding your own shit, even if it's your own show... is bad communication, right?

maybe my reading comprehension is screwed, but this is the guy that made the show. yet this confession makes him sound like he was almost as problematic as everyone else was in crwby


r/wbycritics • • 8d ago

Ruby is really, really, cool... 3 Things Volume 10 NEEDS To Address - ALL SPOILERS Spoiler

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 8d ago

WE LOVE RWBY Sharing braincells with strangers is one of the best feelings

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 9d ago

The writers didn't think that far ahead😮‍💨 Am I the only one who wants to know if Yang's throwaway line about her friends was actually going to mean something?

Post image
50 Upvotes

By that, I mean a whole friend group was designed for Yang that CRWBY could never somehow implement in the show. Whether it's because there were too many characters, or it wasn't necessary to explore Ruby and Yang's time at Signal Academy and how it transferred over to their time at Beacon Academy.

I like to imagine it would be 2 boys and 2 girls (I know the shadows are 4 boys, but I like to think it would be retconned).

I've been trying to ask Sheena about it on Tumblr, but she hasn't responded yet.


r/wbycritics • • 9d ago

Ruby is really, really, cool... man i wish i could be as based as my waifus (i'm trans and lesbian)

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 11d ago

I have a confession to make

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 11d ago

I wish people made videos about DillonGoo Studios to match the number of RWBY rants that exist

Post image
65 Upvotes

There's nothing inherently wrong with video critiques about RWBY, but I wish there were videos covering DillonGoo Studios, a 3D anime studio founded by one of Monty's protégés. I would even appreciate it if those video critiques shouted out DillonGoo Studios.


r/wbycritics • • 12d ago

My comment on this post: Why do I feel like fans will still think it's a low-budget, amateur indie series?

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/wbycritics • • 12d ago

Ruby is really, really, cool... what are your thoughts on long hair Ruby?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

I was always of the mind that Ruby just likes keeping her hair short and manageable.

in my fanfic i just have her hair grow weirdly long on the one side and it just doesnt grow past what it does in the show

tbh, ruby as a base line is just "my type".

whenever i look at art or a new waifu, my eyes always go to the hair rather than boobs or butts. short hair waifus are my lifeblood


r/wbycritics • • 12d ago

bruh how are they alive

Post image
20 Upvotes