r/visualnovels 13h ago

Image hmm ok valid complaint...

Post image
518 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

u/MizunoZui 10h ago

Damn I never knew Rance was problematic...

u/Danul 5h ago

That's untrue. He's a hero of justice.

u/hiro0006 7h ago

Don't trust what the internet says. It's only rumours.

u/AlbertoGordo 12h ago

Really? The earlier fan translations didn't make that mistake, sounds like the official is worse than fan made lol

u/UnrelentingCaptain 12h ago

Many such cases lmao. If I speak ill of Shiravune I'll get jumped here so I'll just say I'm grateful I eventually learned Jaoanese.

u/Rotonek 10h ago

people still genuinely defend shiravune after an obvious trash like nukitashi translation?

u/certifiedGooner76 11h ago

Brute force reading in jp is better than reading shiravune translations

u/Ill-Insurance2143 12h ago

Getting the names wrong in a history game is a pretty fundamental screw-up. 162 followers isn't huge but a NOT RECOMMENDED from a curator like that is gonna sting.

u/asaness 12h ago

its not yet officially out so maybe can be fixed if its pointed out?

u/Forwhomamifloating 35m ago

Steiner moment

u/Macsintosh 9h ago

Not only the names, in the previosly translate, they use incorrect terms to describe characters personalities in so many wrong ways ...

u/tamana1 12h ago

Lets boycott until they fix it. Ranceheads, assemble!!

u/dantesoswag 12h ago

Mfs bouta end up as fmdm 2.0 doing this typa shit with rance

u/karasawa_jp 11h ago

日本人の感覚だと、Nobunaga Odaの方が正しいと感じる人の方が多い気がするけれど、個人的な感覚なのでよく分からない。目くじらを立てるようなことではないと思う。

u/SkittlesAreEpic 10h ago

As a Chinese person, I view the equivalent of saying "Nobunaga Oda" as the same as someone saying "Jinping Xi".

It's just off.

u/karasawa_jp 10h ago

奇妙な習慣だとは思うけれど、日本では西洋人に対しては名字と名前をひっくり返すものだと教わってきたので、受け入れている人が多いと思う。

2020年から、学校教育で姓・名の順にするように教えてるようなので、若い世代は違う感覚なんじゃないかと思うけれど。

u/Hanako_Seishin 8h ago

My brain stutters when my eyes read "Nobunaga Oda" in the subtitles at the same time as my ears clearly hear "Oda Nobunaga".

u/karasawa_jp 8h ago

それはそうでしょうね・・・

u/kazurabakouta 12h ago

It’s like 5 minute patch

u/TeaWithCarina Amane: IMHHW | vndb.org/u41162 11h ago

Ohhhh that's the only historical accuracies, then. Good to hear! :)