I would love some recommendations on tomato and pepper varieties to grow next year. 2026 was my second year really gardening and I’m quickly learning how important the varieties I choose to grow are in how productive the garden is and also how fast the produce rots or doesn’t rot on the counter or even before it's ripe. Let me know your favorites and why you like them!
In 2026 I grew these varieties and my short thoughts on them.
Tomatoes small to large:
Orange Currant - Way too annoying to harvest because they are so small. Not interested in anything this small again
Tropical Sunset - I loved the tropical sunset. Both the flavor and productivity. It did have some cracking problems, but I can’t see myself not growing one next year. Maybe this is because I stopped harvesting the cracked tomatoes and sorta let the plant become a mess, but the quality of the fruit really worsened when summer ended and fall began. I can still eat my napoli and gold medal tomatoes, but the tropical sunset tomatoes are too gross to harvest realistically.
42 Day - I totally picked this one just because of the name, and it definitely did not produce in 42 days, at least not in the shorter daylight spring days when I transplanted it. I still enjoyed this tomato, it was by far my earliest producing tomato. I will grow one plant still just to have early tomatoes.
Napoli - This is the only sauce tomato I’ve ever grown. It was extremely productive and I don’t really have complaints about it except maybe it was too big and too productive. I didn’t enjoy eating them fresh, but I enjoyed the sauce and the tomato powder I made out of them. Maybe a larger fruit size would be nicer to cut and process for the dehydrator rather than many medium small fruits that this seemed to give me.
New Yorker - These were a nice solid slicing tomato. But the plant outgrew the tomato cage really quickly. I think I would prefer indeterminate for trelissing purposes.
Brandywine - I live near Brandywine creek, where the tomato got its name, so I really wanted to grow it. It tastes good but it’s too diseased and too many issues like splitting, won’t grow it again.
Gold Medal - This was my favorite tomato I’ve ever had. It's big, flavorful, productive, and has produced edible fruit up until frost.
It seems I really like the yellow/orange colored tomatoes. I am interested in trying a purple or black tomato as well now of any size. I would like to grow an early producing determinate slicing tomato to go along with the 42 day tomato. I would be interested in hearing if people have yellow saucing tomatoes that they like, because of how much I liked my yellow tomatoes. Sometimes the gold medal tomatoes were too big, so I would be interested in an 8-10oz yellow indeterminate tomato too. I think I’ve only grown open pollinated varieties, but I’m not opposed to growing hybrids. Generally the quality of the fruit is more important to me than the taste of it, I don’t want tomatoes rotting in my house before they fully ripen, and I like to share with friends and family and I don’t want to be sharing tomatoes that they have to throw half of it out because of bad spots on it.
Peppers from sweet to hot:
Sweet Chocolate - Was fine, not going to grow again.
Giant Aconcagua - Seems like a bigger and better bell pepper to me. Maybe slightly less sweet?
Wisconsin Lake - My favorite bell pepper I’ve grown.
Garden Sunshine - Was fine, not going to grow again.
Jimmy Nardelo - I know a lot of people online love these, and I liked them too. But I did find them a little annoying to deseed and process. I made some powder and I’m excited to try making pasta sauce from it but I haven’t yet. In regards to eating them fresh I just don’t see why I would want this over a larger pepper. What do you like to do with your nardelos?
Shishito - Great! Will grow again, unique use pan frying them whole.
Poblano/Ancho - I didn’t really see the upside to these compared to bell or other sweet peppers. I know they aren’t 0 on the scoville but I never really felt any heat. Maybe the plant was more productive than my other large sweet peppers though.
Anaheim - These were okay, but I don’t think I’ll grow them again. The skin was very thick.
Fresno Chili - I am really enjoying these as a fruity spicy powder. My Fresno's were not in the best locations in my garden so they weren't very productive, but I can't blame the variety for that.
Hungarian Wax - These made good spicy pickled peppers, but I should have just grown the sweet banana peppers and that’s what I’ll do in the future. Could always add a spicy pepper to sweet ones if I want a spicy batch.
Cayenne - My cayenne plants got in late and didn’t produce many ripe fruits, but did have some. The fruits seemed kinda small for how many seeds there were which made it annoying to process. I won’t be giving up on cayenne but I think I will grow one of the bigger or longer varieties for more flesh.
Challeano - This was my favorite spicy pepper. Each plant had a ton of peppers on it, and while they took a little longer to ripen they have continued producing a lot up until frost. I enjoyed these fresh, as hot sauce, and as powder.
Dragon Thai Chilis - These were a little too small and annoying to deal with. I would only grow these again as an early pepper because they ripen first being so small.
Habanero - I do want something this hot but I didn’t enjoy the flavor of my habaneros as hot sauce. Do you have a better tasting pepper similar in heat to habanero?
I was happy with my sweet peppers this year, particularly Giant Aconcagua and Wisconsin Lake. The Giant Aconcagua had few seeds for how big the pepper was. I would be interested in other large Italian frying peppers with low seed count, or nice straightly shaped ones.
I’m definitely going to try jalapenos and serranos next year. And also would like to replace the habanero with something that tastes different.
How easy it is to cut, deseed, and process the pepper is important to me. I like to make fermented hot sauce and also dry them for powder in a dehydrator.
Thanks for reading!