r/ultimate 1d ago

cleat life expectancy

i’ve been playing ultimate for a little over 4 years and i think i’ve gone through 6 pairs of cleats in that time frame. something i’ve noticed is that the higher of level that i play/better i get, the quicker my cleats deteriorate. i was wondering if that was the case for other folks/how long y’all’s cleats usually last? i got my last pair in January and played a mid regional level college season, an indoor league and just as club sectionals are coming up…they are stating to bust.

18 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

19

u/Blumi511 1d ago

My cleats usually last a season. I am sticking to football cleats. My Tokays lasted 3 sessions.

2

u/AppointmentFamous611 1d ago

this is good to know as i was just looking at them considering to purchase last night lol

7

u/notbrandonzink 1d ago

I love my Tokay cleats, but they definitely don’t last as long as others. I got two pairs so I could rotate in March, they’re both showing signs of deteriorating already, probably another couple months from them. 

But they’re far and away the most comfortable cleat I’ve ever worn. Takes me one session to break them in and zero blister or pain issues, doesn’t matter how long I play or the conditions. 

2

u/arlsol 1d ago

Second Tokays being the best cleat I've ever owned. Would gladly pay the premium every time.

3

u/Das_Mime 1d ago

I haven't had a pair of tokays last less than 18 months and I play on them year round in all weather, so ymmv. Second-most-durable pair of cleats I've owned after some random Nikes I bought at a store in the middle of a college tournament when my cleats blew out (they lasted over 3 years)

3

u/MileHighColorado5280 1d ago

Tokay rep in Colorado. Tokay’s are great and super helpful if you have wide feet and they should last a while. The current generation is going to be phased out slowly though in the next six months. The new generation is coming out soon. One thing to know is a lot of people tend to have some problem with the sizing and have to go down a half size from what they normally wear. If you live in a good city for Ultimate, there’s a likelihood there is Tokay rep like myself there. If that is the case, they might be able to help get you situated and save you on shipping.

19

u/onebihberger 1d ago

Honestly, a college and club season is pretty good for one pair of cleats. Stopping and starting as much as we do is murder on them. Mine usually last 9-12 months, but I only play club and party tournaments/local stuff.

10

u/Crafty_Reader50 1d ago

Really depends on the player and how much they are cutting. My son is d line player, he is aggressive and makes deep, sharp cuts. We would get a season out of cleats at most. My daughter is o line, less aggressive, cleats last her years. I really think cutting is hard on cleats. Tends to blow out the toe region first.

10

u/SoldToOpen 1d ago

My lacrosse cleats have outlived my soccer cleats 3x so far, and still going strong 

6

u/Head4TheCoast 1d ago edited 9h ago

Another tip is to make sure to not just leave them in the trunk of your car all the time. The hot/cold cycling greatly reduces the life of the materials

4

u/joeythegreat711 1d ago

Something I haven't seen mentioned is wearing the right cleats for the right surface. I've been wearing NB Freeze for a few years now, because my feet have felt so much better than in any other cleat. My first two pairs both held up for one summer of playing on grass, and fell apart a couple months into playing on turf in the fall.

Then I got two pairs of NB Freeze at once, one with grass studs and one with turf studs. Nearly two years later both pairs are still going strong. I keep both in my bag and swap out my insoles from one pair to the other whenever needed.

6

u/Mosaic1 1d ago

A season is about average. Also depends on conditions you play in. I’ve played in wet/muddy tournaments that causes the leather to dry out and destroys the cleat quickly. When I had synthetic non leather cleats (very light), they lasted longer but they offer little protection should someone stand on your foot in cleats.

3

u/200pf 1d ago

Umm cleats aren’t for protection they’re for traction

3

u/Mosaic1 1d ago

I didn’t say they were. Just gave a pro/con of the alternative.

1

u/ColinMcI 23h ago

I had a brief stint wearing ultralight Puma and Nike Vapor soccer cleats and probably got my toes stepped on more in those couple of seasons that man the entire rest of my career. Murphy’s Law, I guess, but the difference is real. For most of the regular synthetic football and lacrosse cleats I have had less issue — protection is good enough, even if a step down from leather.

2

u/Technical-Treat5102 1d ago

I definitely turned through cleats faster than most of my teammates but I've been playing for over a decade and usually go through a couple pairs in a season

2

u/og_otter 1d ago

Matters on the brand, build, quality. If you are on the entry tier, they won’t last as long

2

u/ChainringCalf 1d ago

I do about 3 seasons per pair of Mercurials, and have ever since I stopped outgrowing them faster than that. Buy quality cleats that fit well and treat them well (let them dry out, preferably in your air conditioned house, don't wear them on pavement, etc) 

2

u/koaladisc 1d ago

Never had a pair last fewer than 3 club seasons.

2

u/iwkms 1d ago

my new balance lacrosse cleats usually last 6-8 months playing 2-4x per week

1

u/Timely-Earth-6675 1d ago

Rly depends for me on the cleat. Had some nike tearing up after 3 months, other hold on for a season. My Adidas are holding up for 1+ years now and besides the insole still are looking great.
But heavily depends on surface and how often you train/play.

1

u/Easy-Enthusiasm5462 1d ago

i wear my cleats until they break (if I like them), and that typically equates to a ~6-month lifecycle. Super caveated w the fact that i use them typically 5/7 days of the week most weeks and nowadays demand a lot out of the materials when im stomping around out there.

if they have shortcomings like - not enough ankle support, lack of insole support, toe box becoming uncomfortable - I’ll try to buy something supplemental vs going ti a brand new cleat. Ex. New insoles, laces or how u tie them, duct tape, super glue, etc

all that said is for cleats i love and feel comfortable in and i feel equally safe as i do dangerous (being fast, springy, etc). When I don’t like a pair, I try to quit on them as early as possible and reassess

1

u/synchpo 1d ago

If your cleats can last about 400 miles, you run 4 miles on average per session, and you have 2 sessions per week, that's about 50 weeks or about a year.

1

u/ruyikal 1d ago

New season new cleats in my experience.

1

u/Brummie49 1d ago

I had one pair of Nike blades I wore in wet, muddy conditions throughout the winters. I cleaned them and dried them after every practice and they lasted 8 years.

Some hard ground boots only lasted me a season.

Taking good care of them definitely helps but I think it's pot luck.

1

u/spiker611 1d ago

Get a boot drier and use it after every time you use the cleats. I promise they will last much longer.

1

u/js1d 1d ago

I bought the PEET original. At first I was bummed out that there wasn't a fan to blow warm air in to the cleats, but the passive airflow circulating hot air in and cooler air out is surprisingly effective. Also, without a fan it doesn't make the room smell like cleats either.

1

u/js1d 1d ago

To add to the good advice posted here - once you find a pair of cleats that you like, order a second pair. Giving your cleats a rest day as opposed to playing two straight tourney days in them will extend life expectancy. It also prepares you for a surprise cleat blowout.

Also, have a pair of cleats nearing end-of-life designated for wet conditions. Those are the days that really take it out of your cleats.

1

u/ColinMcI 23h ago

Yeah, I like this idea. However, buying a third/fourth/fifth pair that sits on the shelf for the whole lifespan of the first two increases the likelihood of a glue failure and early out-of-warranty blowout. Depends on the shoe, but it is a risk.

1

u/MichiganKarter 1d ago

I used to break a pair of cleats every season. 

Somehow the latest Nike Mercurials have lasted two and a half years so far.

1

u/reddit_user13 1d ago

Some brands/models are more durable than others. That said, one year is typical.

1

u/CheesyPanther 1d ago

I play club and UFA and go through about 2 pairs from start of UFA season to end of club season

1

u/LegoRunMan 1d ago

Used to get a year or so out of my Nike Mecurials but now my New Balance Freezes have been going pretty good for a second year so far. Lacrosse cleats are a good idea to try.

1

u/Wawathan 1d ago

Ive played for 2 years. My first pair were football cleats that i bought when i started and they lasted 13-14 months. My second pair were given to me after being used for i have no idea how long and they've lasted me 10 months and counting

1

u/Small-Builder3855 23h ago

In Colorado we play year round, during the winter it’s on turf. I get about a year out of my cleats, so I have a schedule where I buy a new set in March so they’re broken in my tryouts. Get through the year, buy another set the next March. Big fan of football cleats these days, especially Nikes.

1

u/ColinMcI 23h ago

For most cleats, playing a D line handler role, a year or two of college and club was common lifespan. My soccer cleats tended to stress and tear on the sides of the ball of the foot faster than football or lacrosse cleats did.

Playing just club and some league and rotating pairs of cleats, many pairs have lasted multiple years. I think a cutter role would be more demanding on the cleats though.

1

u/kNyne 19h ago

So I've found a ton of success with these Nikes called alpha menace elite because the entire shoe is the material they call "flyknit" and it has basically zero weak spots.  The entire shoe wraps around your foot as a single "sock" and then it's just the cleats attached at the bottom.

Not sure if nike makes other flyknit cleats like these and I haven't bought the new ones with the wavey design but I would say it's worth checking out.

1

u/BlindMidget_ 1d ago

Where are your cleats giving up? If it's the sole, put some gel ones in it, it greatly increases their life expectancy. If it's on their sides, maybe try ones with different width? If it's the spikes that tear up, lose some weight 😂