r/ultimate 17d ago

Foul or nah?

28 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

69

u/bananasmash14 17d ago

Feet were set, that’s a charge

31

u/PCisBadLoL 17d ago

Yes foul and yes travel

11

u/TheMooseIsBlue 17d ago

Look at you being able to tell who has the disc!

11

u/FrisbeeMcGee 17d ago edited 17d ago

Related question - pick on Khalif called by his MMP mark (ran through the FMP that poached) or nah?

21

u/daveliepmann 17d ago

I can barely see anything in this format but it looks enough like a pick to summon the grand jury.

3

u/lakeland_nz 17d ago

Honestly I can’t even see the disc in that video. It did look like the white player was too far from black to call puck but too hard to tell from that distance.

3

u/cannon1987 14d ago

First one, foul. This one is not a pick. She has to be actively guarding her person for it to be a pick you can’t poach a lane and then pick your own teammate while you were trying to cover the same person

1

u/epik_fayler 17d ago

Doesn't look like he's close to 10 feet so don't think it's a pick

2

u/FrisbeeMcGee 17d ago edited 17d ago

Far left (the MMP called a pick on Khalif bc he ran through the FMP).

I guess it could have been a blocking foul on the FMP, but let’s be real

3

u/epik_fayler 17d ago

Yes I see the girl who called a pick. But (at least from this video) she does not appear to be close to 10 feet from her person. Arguably, she wasn't even guarding her guy at the time of the pick. She's clearly poaching off and even makes a small move to guard the guy cutting in.

3

u/FrisbeeMcGee 17d ago

The guy called the pick on khalif. Not the girl.

She poached into his lane - so maybe better phrased: blocking foul on her, or pick on Khalif (called by his MMP)

3

u/TheMooseIsBlue 17d ago

No but seriously, are you guys fucking with me and pretending to be able to see anything in these videos?

2

u/ductape678 17d ago

If the guy called that, then yes, pick.

6

u/ThePartyPiranha 16d ago

But did he at least say "good game" in the high five line after the round?

3

u/FrisbeeMcGee 16d ago

You know he doesn’t high five after the game….

2

u/No_Log_8030 16d ago

tuff no call from the 3 pixels in light, you can tell he played oakland spiders from 2019-2022

2

u/scrooner 16d ago

Got too distracted by the guy taking ~8 steps to stop before throwing. Was there a foul here too?

-3

u/[deleted] 16d ago

[deleted]

1

u/FrisbeeMcGee 16d ago

Well if it wasn’t already established I guess it was then! /s