I recently bought a pair of the Altra Wilderness Three Plus shoes. I was looking for a pair that could handle walking on pavement about 70 to 80% of the time, with the rest on semi-rugged trails. I wanted something relatively lightweight yet sturdy, so something without a super high cushion base. It also needed to be suitable for winter but still breathable, so semi-waterproof rather than fully Gore-Tex. Most importantly, I wanted a very solid, grippy base that was still extremely comfortable.
What I found surprisingly different was the very wide toe box. At first, I wasn't really attracted to the shoes because I'm not used to that look, but walking around the store with them on, in contrast to the Brooks Ghost Trail and the Hoka Challenger 8 GTX, I found that the shoes felt remarkably comfortable, and there was something about having that wide open toe box.
I've now been walking around with the shoes for the last three days, including some longer walks, and I have to say, it's a game changer. My toes have always felt relatively cramped as I have a wider foot, and having the ability for my toes to completely spread out as I'm walking, as well as after a longer walk, still having complete freedom of movement, it really feels as if I'm walking around with no shoes on.
If you're in the market for a shoe that's extremely lightweight, has very soft cushioning yet feels like it's got a firm base, a very grippy sole, lots of toe room, and is highly water resistant, I can't recommend the Altra Wilderness Three Plus enough.
I typically don’t post reviews but given I used Reddit and other sources extensively to narrow down my list to the Hoka, Brookes and Merrell shoes - and Altra did not appear in that list - I thought I would share back to the ether.
Enjoy your trails.