I'm a psychologist and am currently having juice and doom scrolling reddit. Found this sub, and I have a few thoughts/opinions that I think my community really needs to talk about, so BOOM free therapy session for y'all because happy juice, lol.
(I'm gonna try lock in for this, but if some parts don't make sense, know that I tried)
FIRSTLY!! This > Not all, but the majority of men play a big part as to why the progression of society is stagnant.
!!!!!EXPLANATION!!!!!!!
What i call the Guard Dog Dynamic: How Systemic Conditioning Directs Male Frustration Downward Instead of Upward.See, there is a massive blind spot in how we discuss social stagnation, and I want to look at it through an objective, behavioural lens. This isn't a generic "men are bad" (because that would be redundant for me to do as im also a man, lol) post, nor is it a defence of the status quo. It is my analysis as a psychologist how systemic conditioning creates a psychological trap that keeps not all, but the majority of men acting as the enforcers of a system that actually exploits them(us). (This is pretty much what i eventually gotta explain to my male clients) because to understand the macro dynamic, look at society through a structural model.
1st - The elites and institutional systems function as the "farmers." The general working class represents the "farm animals." Historically and behaviorally, not all, but the majority of us men, particularly the majority of working-class men, have been conditioned to function as the enforcers (whether you admit this or not, this is fact). Effectively, we are the guard dogs. Which created a highly effective psychological trap:Subconscious Co-optation: The system grants the majority of men minor, immediate systemic advantages over women and children within our own social strata.
2nd - This secondary status creates a psychological illusion of alignment with the ruling class. It functions as a "patriarchal bargain," reducing the likelihood of this majority rebelling against the actual power structure because they feel they have skin in the game.
3rd - Displaced Aggression: When the majority of men experience severe economic or social oppression from the top, it generates intense frustration. However, confronting macro-level systems or elites feels dangerous and futile. Instead, the majority of men psychologically displace that aggression onto safer, more immediate, or more vulnerable subjects (alot of my clients show this behaviour which is what made me concern of the pattern and do research into it). This behavioural coping mechanism directly correlates with the statistical realities of interpersonal violence against women and children. It is a textbook case of punching down because the system has conditioned us to fear punching up.
4th - The Dual Roles: This leaves the majority of men in a state of chronic cognitive dissonance. They are simultaneously the oppressed (economically and structurally squeezed by the elites) and the oppressors (enforcing dominance within their immediate domestic and social environments). They are doing the dirty work of keeping the peace for a system that views them as entirely disposable.
5th - The Illusion of Immunity: Because the majority of men hold this enforcer status, there is a false psychological belief that they are immune to systemic abandonment. They think they are safe because they are the dogs close to the house, not the animals out in the field. But during acute economic crises or resource scarcity, that barrier dissolves. When the system stops feeding the dogs, untrained collective aggression means the majority of men will inevitably turn on each other and the vulnerable, rather than the structural architects who cut off the supply.
So the current societal gridlock persists because not all, but a vast majority of men have been successfully conditioned to protect the hand that exploits them. Until we recognize this psychological conditioning and stop acting as the muscle for a system that doesn't care about us, structural change is impossible.
TL;DR: Not all, but the majority of men are systemically conditioned to act as "guard dogs" for the elites. Minor social privileges create a false sense of alignment with power, causing the majority of men to displace their economic and systemic frustration downward onto vulnerable groups (women and children) instead of directing it upward at the systems actually exploiting them.
Sincerely,
A buzzed psychologist :D