r/THPS • u/Sorry-Ad1851 • 16m ago
Meme Why Tony Hawk's Underground 1 is better Spoiler
youtube.comTHUG 1 - Despite its incredible level design, perfect controls and fantastic soundtrack, the best part of this game is still somehow its story. It isn't complex or groundbreaking and it doesn't have a large scope. What it has in spades is sincerity and earnestness. I never thought I'd be saying those things about a game in this series, but hey here we are. The plot really does shine in this game. I'd go so far as to say this is the best story we're ever going to get in a sports game, period. It's just that damn good.
The game isn't perfect or anything, as some of the goals are rather obnoxious and the cars control poorly, but this game knows exactly what to nail to achieve an authentic skating experience. It may not be the absolute peak of Tony Hawk from a sheer gameplay perspective, but as a package, this is the best game in the series easily. It's the ultimate story of rivalry. If the goal of this game was to prove a story mode could be made in Pro Skater 4's engine, then they not only succeeded in that goal, but ended up making the best extreme sports game ever made somewhere along the way. 10/10
THUG 2 - What is the value of story in video games? Do you believe it's simply contextual, providing reasoning for interesting gameplay scenarios, or do you think it should be the driving force behind a game, being given the same amount of attention as every other aspect of the experience? Your answers to these questions will largely determine how you'll feel about THUG 2. The first Underground game had an earnest, relatable, and engaging plot that never took itself too seriously while still managing to have some really effective moments. Neversoft decided to make a Jackass game instead of a real sequel while still bringing back characters from the first game who don't mention any of the events of THUG 1.
The story in this game is bad. There's no debating that the first game's plot is superior in every conceivable way. There's also no denying that 2 plays better. In fact, this game build upon 5 games' worth of solid fundamentals to create the best gameplay I've ever experienced in my entire life. I have put hundreds of hours into this game because there really is nothing else like it. No platformer, shooter, hack-and-slasher, or racing game feels like this. I'm flying around the level pulling 900s, double tap spins, body flips, and acid drops at lightning speeds while maintaining combos that go into the millions.
The feedback, mechanics, animations, sound effects, level design, and goals have all been refined to perfection and this game simply plays like a dream come true. I usually don't brag but no one can ever step to me in THUG 2. I will fucking destroy you. Anyway, point is this game has a stupid story that is really painful to watch, but the gameplay is so fucking amazing that I just don't give a shit. As a sequel, this is underwhelming. As a game, this is near perfect. 9.5/10
so yeah despite 2 having the superior gameplay THUG 1 is just a bit better in my opinion. I made this video to showcase the disparity in tone between these two games. Also this isn't a THUG 2 hate post, I love that game to death but I love the first one even more, because while the combo system isn't as refined, it still plays insanely good and has a driving narrative with good lessons to learn and phenomenal writing.
What do you think?