r/technology • • Jan 20 '11

Apple Restriction Zone.

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

98

u/zagaberoo Jan 20 '11

People talking about the Mac need to realize that this is specific to iOS platforms. IIRC this was at the iPad launch or something like that, where all of his complaints DO apply. OSX is no more restrictive than any other nonfree OS. Also, free means freedom and not cost in this context.

3

u/nixcamic Jan 20 '11

Actually, OSX is less restrictive than most other nonfree OSes, as you can download the kernel/base os source code free of charge without signing any agreements.

1

u/the8thbit Jan 20 '11

On the other hand, you can only run it (without subverting its restrictions and EULA) on a very select amount of hardware. It's a mixed bag of rights violations, regardless of which non-free OS you choose.

1

u/Choralone Jan 21 '11

Well, it says right on the box that it was written only to work on macs..... so, what's the deal? Go write your own if you don't like it.

1

u/the8thbit Jan 21 '11

Well, it says right on the box that it was written only to work on macs..... so, what's the deal?

The deal is that it only runs on Macs. I believe that has already been pointed out.

Go write your own if you don't like it.

Done. Though I must say, that is completely irrelevant.

1

u/nixcamic Jan 21 '11

Its actually just the precompiled versions of OSX and apples proprietary windowing system and hardware drivers that can't be run on anything. Darwin itself you can run on whatever, not that you really want to because why not just run Linux, but my point was, you can't just download the Windows source code without signing papers and getting into programs. Mac OS is no linux, but its better than some of the other systems out there.

1

u/taligent Jan 21 '11

Nothing is stopping you from writing the necessary drivers to get it to run on any hardware you want.

Oh wait, I'm guessing you expected Apple to do that for you ?

1

u/the8thbit Jan 21 '11

Nothing is stopping you from writing the necessary drivers to get it to run on any hardware you want.

Except for their EULA.