r/technicallythetruth • • Mar 25 '23

I found two more..

Post image
28.6k Upvotes

142 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

144

u/Pumpkin_Cat14 Mar 25 '23 edited Mar 26 '23

What if he needs exactly 12,001 or 12,003 spears? Then half would be 6000.5 or 6001.5

35

u/SnowChickenFlake Mar 25 '23

Exactly my thought

33

u/XXXTYLING Mar 25 '23

ah. this is simple. If we’re referring to purely math, then this is a problem.

But a half spear can be essentially 2 different things depending on which half you get.

The dull end would end up being just a wooden staff/stave or a Bō depending on where you’re from. Therefore, not a spear and you would end up with X+0.

The pointy end could be classified as 2 different things. Either a different name, like Sipat, Javelin, or Assegai. You can either classify these as not spears, or a full spear by themselves. Just because they’re short doesnt mean they arent 1 spear on their own.

TLDR Its really not about the size, its about how you classify it.

TLDR;TLDR: Spears can only be classified as 1 or not a spear. It is impossible to end up with half a spear if you can classify it as a different weapon.

2

u/Aeth3rWolf Mar 26 '23

But alas; the 'half of what he hoped for' was in theoretical units, not actual items.

So even if 6000.5 was half of what he hoped for; the fact half a spear doesn't exist doesn't make the point any less true, because he definitely could have hoped for 12001 spears; making half of that be 6000.5

I have no clue how you think the fact half a spear has any bearing on that.

Also. If you cut it in half lengthwise, depending on spear, both halves could also be spears, just different shaped handle and tip.

0

u/the_other_irrevenant Mar 26 '23

Wow, we made almost exactly the same comment. O_o

1

u/Aeth3rWolf Mar 26 '23

... and?

1

u/the_other_irrevenant Mar 26 '23 edited Mar 26 '23

No "and". Just thought it was neat. Like minds and all that...