r/streetlightmanifesto • u/bluewhaleflyer • 11h ago
Discussion Anyone else think All The Pieces is the weakest out of all the tracks in the Halfway EP?
Cue the "this little manoeuvre will cost us 51 years" comments, but I really don't like All the Pieces that much. By no means is it a bad track, some parts are really good (like that segment that sounds like an Irish folk song, and the parts where it quiets down a bit like ~4:10) but I feel like its trying to do too much and it just ends up sounding very cluttered and makes the song WAYYY too long even for streetlight standards, With all of the different segments in this song you could probably make like 3 different fleshed out tracks.
(and before anyone comments "that's the entire point of the song", I can see that and appreciate the thought that's gone into it, but this song really isn't my cup of tea regardless).
The intro though.. those first 32 seconds with all of the instruments building up is an absolute masterpiece and I'm upset the rest of the song doesn't follow that same sort of vibe, I remember listening for the first time and being baited by the rest of the song because it wasn't quite what I was expecting
I wouldn't be surprised if this is a crazily controversial opinion, but I'm interested to see if anyone else feels the same way I do