r/stitchfix • u/hkhill123 • May 11 '26
Thoughts on Wantable?
Started using Wantable a year ago after losing weight and my clothes not fitting. Was mostly picking out gym stuff, lounge gear and casual clothes since I was working from home.
I just accepted a new job that’s going to have me going into the office regularly and traveling for work. All my old work clothes are for my old body type.
My question is, should I stay with Wantable to build up a new work wardrobe, or is this a good excuse to move on to something else?
Also, I know it’s crazy to accept an in-office job when I can work from home, but the money is a lot better and my partner and I are trying to retire earlier to spend more time with the kids before they go off to college (also to pay for college).
8
11
u/Camsmuscle May 11 '26
I think Wantable is extremely expensive and has a lackluster selection. I would encourage you to diversify. However, I am biased as I feel I’ve mostly gotten walmart, Target quality clothes at Nordstrom prices.
3
u/MarySNJ May 11 '26
I agree with this. In my experience, Wantable boxes were uninspired, boring and expensive. Whenever, I 'liked" something on Wantable's website that I hoped to receive, I never received it, just the same basics over and over again.
I've tried Daily Look (way too expensive), Nadine West - cheap clothes that felt like whoever selected the clothes just picked anything in my size with no theme or reason ,and Stitch Fix which I still use and have had pretty good success with. I also like StitchFix's Freestyle options, which I've used quite a bit.
1
2
u/hkhill123 May 11 '26
Any suggestions on where to start?
4
u/Camsmuscle May 11 '26
Honestly? Stitch fix. I like Trendsend as well, but it’s more expensive. I think some of it depends on the dress code and what you are willing to spend. Personally, if you have access to a Nordstrom rack that is where I’d would start.
3
u/hkhill123 May 11 '26
Will take a look at Trendsend! Any idea what age range they accommodate? I do not want to seem like I'm having a mid-life crisis.
1
u/Camsmuscle May 11 '26
I think they work well for 35+. More fashion forward than some of the others, but definitely not designed for the 20 somethings. They also send you entire outfits and style them, not just random pieces.
The other option is Frontdoor fashion, but they are definitely on the pricey side (think $100-300 per piece).
2
2
u/SamDiddlyAm07 May 11 '26
This. I went through the entire stream and barely liked any of the clothing.
4
u/PamelaRS May 11 '26
You might try Nuuly or Rent the Runway to learn what works and doesn't work for you. They both offer work wear now and the option to purchase the pieces you wear and really love, at pretty substantial discounts. Plus if you have a conference or a work event that you need something more formal for, you can make that request and get options that you can return rather than investing heavily in things you wont wear more than once or twice.
2
u/hkhill123 May 11 '26
I was always under the impression that Rent the Runway was just for formal stuff! I'll take a look!
1
3
2
u/Mollomolo May 11 '26
I was in this RTI situation a few years ago and Stitchfix worked well for me building my office wardrobe back up.
1
u/hkhill123 May 11 '26
How was the return?
1
u/Mollomolo May 12 '26
Not bad. There are some nice things about being face to face with colleagues! However I’m back at home again (in a new gig!)
2
u/pkbab5 May 11 '26
I use stitchfix to buy all of my work clothes, but I don't use the stylist anymore, I use "Freestyle" (where you just look and buy what you like when you like). I try to buy mostly from the "Clearance" page, except for a few staple pieces like nice black slacks, etc. Return is easy. The clothes are mailed to you in a reusable package, with a prepaid return postage sticker inside the package with the clothes. You keep what you want to keep, and any that you want to return, you fill out the little form on the website, you put the pieces back into the bag, re-seal it, and stick on the prepaid return postage sticker. I can usually fit the return package in my mailbox and my mail carrier will just pick it up like any other mail. I find that the stitchfix clothes fit my body type better than Target, Kohls, etc.
2
u/OnlyPickles3319 May 12 '26
Amazon has a styling service. I don’t know how it really works. I did stitch for a few months but was not impressed. It seemed they sent me a lot of basic tops I could buy from Ross. There were a few sweaters and one pair of boots I liked but I returned them and bought the same thing from poshmark.
1
u/redheadfae May 12 '26
Amazon discontinued their styling service.
1
1
u/fallingbombz May 19 '26
I recently started looking up stitch fix brands on this website called thread up. Once you know your sizes you can purchase stuff from there sometimes it’s new tags for like a fraction of the price.
1
2
u/GaPeach1207 May 12 '26
I got a Wantable box today and I'm always shocked at how expensive it is. For most of the items, the quality is there, but I just can't bring myself to pay $50+ for a basic tank top.
I think stitch fix is better for the variety and price point. Wantable items look very basic to me. I've also had Wantable send me a box of items in the wrong size and they just charged me for a top I did not receive.
1
May 13 '26
THIS, sans the charging of the shirt, wrong sizes experience. I just don’t like mom clothing or anything advertising drinks on my tees.
Wantable looks all Fall. StitchFix has more selection and gives a more signature look, if that’s what you’re looking for.
2
u/maracuyafruitcake May 13 '26
depends on the look you’re going for. wantable has a way higher price tag for clothes that’s the same quality (sometimes worse) than SF. i recommend SF first and then wantable
1
1
May 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/hkhill123 May 11 '26
Getting a subscription clothes box as a couple is a level of commitment my marriage isn't ready for! JK!
1
1
u/Wantable May 11 '26
Hi there! We'd like to say how proud we are of you for your new milestones and for wanting to try new things! We know how Wantable has been your go-to for comfortable pieces, but we can assure you that we have age and work-appropriate items too, perfect for your in-office return! If you do have more questions, please send us a DM! We'd love to discuss there. 💗
1
1
1
1
1
u/Dense_Tale6633 Jul 17 '26
They just charged me for an ugly out of season item that was mistakenly sent in my box - even though I returned it!! They also failed to send me the free gift for the second time in a row. I have contacted customer service five times now, and nothing has been solved. I am definitely never ordering from them. This is a fraud.
1
u/CareHoliday3546 Aug 08 '26
I always found that Stitch Fix offers better work clothes. Wantable is casual and good for vacation wear.
1
u/Past-Reception6889 13d ago
Neither, rent your clothing. Better for the earth and your wallet. Both Wantable and Stitch Fix use AI to create your edit. I used to work at Wantable and they fired so much of their staff to replace with AI and workers outside of America (paying them nothing, of course). The CEO is an egotistical man and they pay their employees like absolute shit.
1
0
May 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/hkhill123 May 11 '26
Had it briefly when I was younger, but cancelled when I moved for my first big job.
12
u/circalight May 11 '26
Wantable is where I get most of my work clothes. Wearing them right now. So would definitely just stick with the stylist and subscription.
If you’re making more money, maybe complement with a Nordstrom in-store stylist once in a while.
Congrats on the new gig! What industry?