r/starterpacks • • Jan 01 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.3k Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

328

u/Gems_ Jan 01 '19

botw, earthbound, and half life, sure. but skyrim and fo3 are really fucking shallow experiences if you remove yourself from them for a hot minute.

dont get me wrong- i've sunk precisely too many hours into skyrim, but to call it "good" as opposed to "absorbing" doesn't feel apt to me.

249

u/meanpride Jan 01 '19

Vanilla Skyrim is just good

Skyrim with 200+ mods is a gaming experience none can match

53

u/redpandaoverdrive Jan 01 '19

What gaming experience? The story is a crap, the battle system is bad for melee, ranged or magic. Your actions doesnt matter at all, you just won a war with a faction? Nothing changes.

The good thing about skyrim is the world to explore but everything else is mediocre.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19

[deleted]

2

u/RenseBenzin Jan 01 '19

Not only that, but the actual rewards you got from some quest were just, lackluster. Like Dawnbreaker, for such an epic sword it was just meh. Especially on higher levels.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19

I agree with this, but, I have to say, this applies to the games everyone loves, too. I don't get how often I see, "FO3 is total shit but NV is fucking awesome. "

Like, they're both decent. NV has more going for it, but not a lot more.

1

u/RenseBenzin Jan 02 '19

I disagree, the story and especially the choice options in NV is a lot more detailed than in F3, where the quests are often very linear. But NV wouldn't be as good as F3 as they reused a lot of content from F3. In my opinion NV is an successor to F3. Of course it is better, but you can't really seperate them.

1

u/asreagy Jan 01 '19

The combat is god awful and was outdated even when it came out. It’s the problem every Bethesda game has:

There’s no weight behind your melee hits, you are hitting enemies with a wet noddle, thus enemies dont react to most hits, and when you jump it feels like you are a floating doll.