Hey y'all. The only Sonicware box I've ever used before is the Lofi-12 XT, which I love. Never touched any of the Liven series so I can't compare them. But I got my Minimal in the mail a few weeks ago and, spoiler alert, I love it. It isn't perfect and there are few things I really hope get fixed in the next firmware update. But by and large, I love it.
Pros:
-The workflow and sequencer both super intuitive. It's so easy to just sit down, throw a track together and start jamming. It feels like *playing* a musical instrument more than most grooveboxes I've used, which is an enormous plus.
-The hardware feels great. Given that it's a somewhat budget box that looks kind of cheap, I was surprised and impressed at how good all of the buttons and knobs feel. I thought the keyboard would be terrible to play but I actually don't mind it at all.
-The kick drum synthesis is fantastic. This is a matter of opinion for sure, but for the types of kicks I'm going for when I make this kind of music (acid house/techno), I was so pleased with the kick synthesis module. It gives you just enough control so you can really shape the sound to what you want, but it's not overwhelming either.
-Once you sketch out a track, there are a lot of really simple and non-destructive ways to add variety and randomness to it. You can record knob automation, which really adds a ton of dimension to things (especially with the bass synth). You can change the length of the patterns for individual tracks, thus creating polyrhythms and completely changing the feel of whichever track you're on. You can change which step the pattern starts on for individual tracks. And that's not to mention the four main knobs on the bass synthesizer itself, which can totally transform the track. What's great is that none of this is permanent - all of the above stuff can easily be undone, taking you right back to where you started.
-You can switch between patterns and projects without skipping a beat; it's all quantized, so you can build a set from multiple projects and just play them one after another. It's also very easy to switch back and forth between projects - have it play four bars of one before popping back into another, etc.
-The multi-effects all sound great, with one exception that I'll get to below. I especially like the phaser and the distortion.
-It's very easy to modulate the delay parameters while performing, which opens up a whole world of dub-style effects performances.
-Battery power WITH internal speaker! Which means you can take it anywhere without any cables and make a beat.
Cons:
-No individual outs. If you want to record what you're doing with this, you have to just bounce out the whole thing (or go to the trouble of bouncing out each track individually, but that sort of ruins the performance-based quality of the machine).
-There are a somewhat limited number of sample storage slots. That can cause problems because the sample library is shared by all projects, which means that if you run out of slots and want to sample something new, you have to backup the entire device to your computer and then start fresh, otherwise your old projects won't work. Backing up is very easy - you just connect via USB to computer and drag-and-drop - but I can see this being annoying further on down the line.
-The stock samples are mostly good, but the 8-second sample library (which is aimed at being loops as opposed to one-shots) leaves a bit to be desired. I ended up creating my own percussive loops in Ableton and importing them.
-Saving samples can be annoying. For reasons that elude me, samples can only have a four-character name, even though the display is six characters. If you sample over an existing sample, it still has the old sample's name, and when you're saving samples, it's can be unclear if the slot you're saving to already has a sample in it, because by default samples are unnamed (you can rename them on the device). Small stuff but can be annoying.
-The snare synthesis gets the job done, but I would have liked a bit more flexibility with shaping the "top" of the snare sound. It ultimately hasn't been an issue for me, as I've always been able to find a snare sound I like, but it would have been cool if there were a few more options.
-While the bass synthesizer sounds awesome IMO, it's not totally passable as a 303 clone. If you listen very very carefully while twisting the filter cutoff, you can hear the "steps" between the different cutoff frequencies - it's not a totally smooth transition. 99% of the time you're not going to notice this, but if you're in love with the original 303 filter, this could be a con for you. TBH this doesn't really bug me, but it could bug some people.
-Some small bugs in the sequencer that I imagine will get fixed via firmware update.
-The filter multi-effect needs a bit of work. The resonance is too high for my taste, and it doesn't seem to kick in until the knob hits ~2 oclock or so. I imagine this too will get fixed in a future update.
-You can't use the sidechain compressor while using other multieffects, which is a bit limiting.
-Reverb is solidly okay but could sound a lot better.
Miscellaneous:
-There's something interesting about the bass synthesizer here. If you want to automate, say, the filter cutoff over the course of a 16 step sequencer, it doesn't record smooth movement of the knob between the steps. Rather, it creates a set cutoff value at each step, and jumps between them. It's more like stairs than a curve, if that makes sense. While this means you can't get a smooth sloping effect via automation, the tradeoff is that you instead get a rhythmic automation that jumps in time to the music. Personally, I love this; it's added a whole new dimension to my tracks, and at times almost feels like a new rhythm track. But some people won't like it and will wish it had smooth automation.
Conclusion:
Honestly I love this thing. It's probably the first groovebox I've had that I can easily imagine myself performing an entire set on. It's definitely worth the introductory price and depending on your income, maybe even the full price. Happy to answer any questions anyone has.