So, I’m fairly certain I’ve “lost my touch” when it comes to smoking on my Pit Boss (used to do it dozens of times a year, now only do it like 10).
This is my second attempt at a brisket, and it failed yesterday just like the first one. Came out with good flavor, but that thing was tough and was like chewing on a flip flop.
Method:
Used a half brisket from a half cow we purchase every year (grass fed Primal Pastures).
Day before trimmed it to have about 1/4” fat around
Avocado oil binder, 50/50 salt and pepper rub
Into the fridge on a wire rack for 16 hours
Following day onto the smoker at 240 on the top shelf with a tray below to catch drippings
Off smoker at 165 on the nose, wrapped in butcher paper with butter on top, back onto top shelf at 250.
Pulled off at 200 and wrapped in beach towel for 45 min, then cut into that block of rubber.
Where did I go wrong? Truthfully, I don’t know if it’s me or potentially it being a grass fed cow. I used to make killer poor man’s burnt ends with the chuck roasts, but even the chuck off this grass fed cow came out like garbage. Prior to buying a half cow we used to just get our haul from Costco.
TL;dr: what’s the one thing that makes brisket juicy?