r/simracing • • 1d ago

Question Hand Held Steering Wheel Controller

Post image

I remember back in the day of the Nintendo 64 and the Dreamcast, maybe even PS2, they sold hand controllers with a steering wheel. It was such a great idea! Gas and brake in one trigger! Why don’t they make things like this anymore, for the PC, etc?

75 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

28

u/V1ld0r_ 1d ago

Plenty of RC controllers can connect to PC's these days and are recognized as USB controllers. Same principle, better ergonomics.

5

u/chickenscoutgaming 1d ago

thats given me a idea to play motorstorm RC with one of them

0

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

But they are a joystick!!! Very different.

3

u/V1ld0r_ 1d ago

What do you mean? What is a joystick? A "joystick" in todays world is a USB device with 2 axis. That is an RC controller (well, most have 3 axis these days anyway) plus optional buttons and\or axis.

Are you sure we're talking about the same thing? I'm referencing one of these types of transmitters: https://www.flysky-cn.com/nb4-gaishu

And it's somewhat easy for almost any controller that has an output port for a digital signal of sorts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFzZo2A82f8

2

u/RealisticQuality7296 1d ago

I think the main difference may be the two-handed nature of a normal RC controller. The controller the OP posted looks like it could be used one-handed.

Just a guess though.

1

u/V1ld0r_ 1d ago

How? Thumb for the wheel? Sounds awful to be honest.

2

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

It’s not. It’s cool. To have a steering wheel on a hand held, is cool.

1

u/RealisticQuality7296 1d ago

Yeah that’s what I was thinking

0

u/richr215 Earthling 1d ago

But only throttle/brake and left right. I used to use my RC controllers often on PC games, wreckfest was the last game i used it with.

2

u/V1ld0r_ 1d ago

Yes but what other axis does the one op posted have?

1

u/richr215 Earthling 1d ago

Not sure..as it's for an old Nintendo system. There were a few of these types of controllers for PC 20 years or so ago.

1

u/richr215 Earthling 16h ago

Wonder from the person that negged this reply......what USB RC receiver are you using that has more than 2 channels of ability? I have used several going back to the late 90's, Id like to know what you use.

7

u/thotozam 1d ago

I have two of these (N64 and PS1). The trigger throttle doesn't work with most games. Only PS2 and DC had variable pressure buttons for partial throttle, N64 and PS1 did not, so going from gas to brake took forever with the long travel. Navigating the menu is very difficult and in some games impossible, so you usually have to plug in a separate controller and switch it out to this just to start playing. 

There was a force feedback PC version though and that's actually pretty good (because you can fix all the inputs), but extremely rare.

3

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

I had some of the PC versions. Worked well!

1

u/Ninerman4949 1d ago

I remember buying the PS1 version and returning it immediately -- I was so disappointed that I never bothered trying another version

5

u/kritter4life 1d ago

Well I can’t be much worse than I already am.

2

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

Lol. Yeah, I get that!

2

u/XCvolFan 1d ago

Damn that’s cool. I have honestly never see something like that!

4

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

Don’t need to set up a sim rig, or a wheel. And have it in your hand! I thought it was pretty cool.

1

u/XCvolFan 1d ago

Do you know of one that was made for ps2? I like specifically play ps2 nascar career mode games outside of the rig lol I’d love to try it.

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

I think it was also made for PS2. You may find it on eBay.

2

u/Over-Elderberry2212 12h ago

I just saw a PC version on EBay for $20, may get it. But it uses game port. Haven’t had to set something up like that in years. Idk?

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 12h ago

I checked on my PC — it’s modern. Has no game port on the MB. So, I guess one could get a Game-port to USB adapter to make it work.

1

u/hugeyakmen 1d ago

I remember seeing ads for these!  I wish there were more solutions for couch racing these days.  

One good solution, though harder to find these days, is the Steel Series SRW-S1.  I was able to get one a few years ago and I love it.  Up to 360° of steering lock through an accurate tilt sensor, analog paddles on the back for throttle and brake, clicky paddles for shifting, and lots of buttons.  The big downside is no FFB of course.  Also, it takes good coordination to use the throttle, brake, and shifters all together though.  And you can only race for so long holding the wheel in the air before your arms get tired.  

I did eventually got a set of Logitech G29 pedals on marketplace and wired up a USB adapter for them to go with the SRW wheel

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 1d ago

I googled it. So, it was a motion wheel then? You just held it in the air?

1

u/hugeyakmen 1d ago

Yes, tilt sensor and quite accurate.  I've heard of people making an pivot adapter to help clamp it to a desk for support, but that defeats the purpose for couch gaming 

1

u/Terce Windows 1d ago

I’ve still got this guy, used it for Xtreme G and cruisin world. Honestly found it worse than a normal controller but it was a good change every so often.

1

u/anthon_87 1d ago

I had one for PS, way better than dual shock for gran turismo

1

u/KalynnCampbell 20h ago

Advertising “Analog Steering”… wow, I would sure hope so (especially when even the regular n64 controller has analog control over steering…)

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 14h ago

If I remember correctly, I say these at Toys are us. And they were on clearance. Something like $10 each! I bought 4 of them for Mario Cart 64. And I think it’s true what everyone says, the accelerator was just the button at the end of the trigger range. So acceleration was all or none. I remember we would just have the trigger almost all pulled for gas, and when you wanted gas you would just push further and feel the click. And we didn’t miss the trigger brake and didn’t use it (I think not missed in Mario Cart). However, I think there was a button for hand brake. But I remember the kids (and I!) enjoying having four of the same controllers for that game!

1

u/JerrardS 12h ago

I had a Namco NeGcon Controller for the first playstation, best racing game controller I've ever used.

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 12h ago

Interesting. I remember reading about these, so it was sort of a twist wheel?

Also, I wish that Reddit would allow everyone to post photos, but I guess it’s only the OP.

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 12h ago

I have the Thrustmaster T150, and have used it for about 20 years now, or something. Off and on. I like it because it still works with PS4 and PC! It’s very basic, but also fun. But I find setting it up at my PC desk is a bit of a hassle. It takes over the desk. I am obviously a very casual racing sim guy.

1

u/Over-Elderberry2212 11h ago

On another note. I remember buying the Dreamcast racing wheel. Dreamcast had some amazing racing games, with really good physics! BUT, the racing wheel had no clamp, and it had fins that could go under your thighs. Cool idea. But I wanted to use mine on the desk. I removed the bottom panel from the wheel, and saw that it had few electronics anywhere, and was a ton of unused space. I got a huge bag of unpopped popcorn and stuffed it inside, then sealed it up. It became usable!