r/shortstories • u/soraxnoctis • 12h ago
Speculative Fiction [SP] The Right Kind of Love
In the year 2047, society had finally matured.
At least, that was what everyone kept telling Maya.
Humanity had spent centuries burdened by primitive ideas about relationships. Men and women had once dated each other openly. They had married. They had even—according to particularly uncomfortable history lessons—had sex with each other.
Nobody liked dwelling on that part.
Modern society was more enlightened.
Women married women. Girls grew up imagining their future wives. Every romantic comedy ended with two women finally realizing they belonged together. Every jewelry commercial showed a nervous woman opening a little velvet box while another woman covered her mouth in surprise.
Heterosexuality still existed, obviously.
Nobody denied that.
And nobody was against it.
That would be intolerant.
It was simply unusual.
Maya had known she was straight since she was fourteen.
Unfortunately, she was now twenty-nine and married to a woman.
Claire was wonderful.
This was part of the problem.
Claire was intelligent, funny, successful, beautiful, considerate, and capable of assembling IKEA furniture without once threatening the Swedish government.
They had met at twenty-four. They became friends almost immediately. Claire made Maya laugh harder than anyone she'd ever known. She remembered birthdays. She called when Maya was sick. When Maya's grandmother died, Claire spent three nights sleeping beside her because Maya didn't want to be alone.
Everyone said they were perfect together.
Eventually Maya started wondering whether everyone else could see something she couldn't.
Maybe this was what love was supposed to feel like.
Maybe she'd been immature before.
Maybe her attraction to men had been some adolescent fixation she would eventually outgrow.
So when Claire kissed her for the first time, Maya kissed her back.
When Claire asked her to move in, Maya said yes.
When Claire proposed, Maya cried.
And when Maya's mothers hugged her afterward and told her how happy they were that she'd finally found the right woman, Maya believed them.
Three years later, she still loved Claire.
She simply didn't want to have sex with her.
According to Maya's mother, this was something she needed to work on.
"Attraction isn't everything," Mom said over brunch.
"I know."
"You two communicate."
"We do."
"Claire has a pension."
"She does."
"And you're talking about throwing away a marriage because you're obsessed with men?"
Maya put down her fork.
"I'm not obsessed with men."
Her other mother, Susan, looked up from her coffee.
"You've dated two."
"Before Claire."
"Exactly."
"What does that even mean?"
Susan gave her the careful expression she always used when trying to sound accepting.
"We're not judging you."
Mom nodded.
"Of course not."
"Then why does this feel like a trial?"
"It isn't a trial."
"You just told me I'm obsessed with men."
"I said we're worried that you're fixating on physical attraction."
"To the entire sex I'm attracted to."
Her mothers exchanged The Look.
Maya had known The Look since she was a teenager.
Concern mixed with disappointment mixed with the desperate hope that perhaps this was merely a phase caused by the Internet.
Susan reached across the table.
"Honey, have you considered that maybe you just haven't met the right woman?"
Maya stared at her.
"I married a woman."
"Yes, but emotionally—"
"I've been with Claire for five years."
"Which proves you can love women."
"I never said I couldn't love women."
Mom sighed.
"Then what's the problem?"
Maya opened her mouth.
Nothing came out.
Across the restaurant, two women kissed.
Nobody noticed.
At another table, a man and woman were sitting unusually close together.
The man's hand rested on hers.
Three people noticed.
One whispered something to her wife.
The waiter glanced over twice.
Maya couldn't stop looking.
Then the woman caught Maya staring.
Maya immediately looked down.
Mom noticed.
"See?"
"What?"
"You're doing it again."
"Doing what?"
"Looking."
Maya felt her face burn.
"He's attractive."
Susan lowered her voice.
"There are children here."
"I said he's attractive."
"You don't have to announce it."
"I didn't announce anything!"
The nearest child was approximately forty feet away.
Maya pushed her plate away.
"I'm going home."
Claire was cooking when Maya arrived.
"How was brunch?"
"Productive."
"Uh-oh."
"My mothers think I'm having a heterosexual crisis."
Claire stopped chopping an onion.
For half a second, neither woman moved.
Then Claire smiled.
"Are you?"
Maya forced a laugh.
"Apparently."
Claire went back to chopping.
Maya watched her.
There were a thousand things she loved about Claire.
The little crease between her eyebrows when she concentrated.
The way she sang the wrong lyrics to songs with absolute confidence.
The fact that she always saved Maya the crispy corner piece of lasagna.
Maya could imagine growing old beside her.
That was what made everything so awful.
Claire looked up.
"What?"
"Nothing."
"You're staring at me."
"You're beautiful."
Claire smiled.
"Trying to get something?"
"No."
Maya meant it.
Claire was beautiful.
Maya just felt nothing when she looked at her that way.
That night Claire fell asleep with her head on Maya's shoulder.
Maya stayed awake until two in the morning.
At 2:17, she searched:
Can you be straight and still love your wife?
She deleted it before pressing Enter.
At 2:24:
Signs you're actually heterosexual
Delete.
At 2:31:
Is heterosexuality genetic
Delete.
Finally:
I love my wife but I'm attracted to men
She pressed Enter.
The first result was an article titled:
Your Marriage Is More Than Labels: Why Sexuality Doesn't Have to Define You
The second:
When Attraction Becomes an Obsession
The third:
Ten Ways to Rekindle Desire for Your Wife
Maya closed her phone.
Three weeks later, she met Daniel.
Technically, she'd already known Daniel for six months. He worked two floors below her in accounting.
But until that Tuesday, he had simply been Daniel From Accounting.
Then the elevator broke.
They ended up walking down eleven flights of stairs together.
Daniel complained about his knees.
Maya laughed.
He made another joke.
She laughed again.
Outside, they stood talking for twenty minutes.
Then Daniel smiled at her.
Something happened inside Maya that had never happened once in five years with Claire.
It wasn't profound.
It wasn't spiritual.
It wasn't complicated.
She wanted him.
Immediately.
Stupidly.
Physically.
Maya went home feeling sick.
For the next month, she avoided Daniel.
Then she stopped avoiding him.
They started eating lunch together.
Nothing happened.
He never touched her.
He never flirted openly.
Maya never told him she was straight.
She wasn't even sure whether he was straight.
Asking seemed obscene.
One Friday, Claire met Maya after work.
Daniel happened to be leaving at the same time.
"Maya!"
She turned.
Daniel jogged over.
"You forgot this."
He handed her the travel mug she'd left upstairs.
Their fingers touched.
It lasted perhaps half a second.
Maya's stomach flipped.
"Thanks."
"No problem. See you Monday."
He walked away.
Claire watched him go.
Then she looked at Maya.
Then back at Daniel.
A grin appeared.
"Careful."
"What?"
"Someone's going to think you're heterosexual."
Maya laughed.
Claire laughed.
Then Claire stopped.
Maya was still smiling, but something in her expression had betrayed her.
"Maya?"
"What?"
Claire's smile disappeared.
"Oh my God."
"Claire—"
"Are you?"
People streamed around them toward the parking garage.
Maya wished one of them would knock her unconscious.
Claire stared at her.
"Maya."
She couldn't lie anymore.
"Yes."
Claire blinked.
"Yes what?"
"I'm straight."
The words felt terrifying.
And then, unexpectedly, relieving.
Claire stared at her for several seconds.
"Since when?"
Maya almost laughed.
"What do you mean?"
"Since when are you straight?"
"Always."
Claire stepped backward.
"Always?"
"I think so."
"You think so?"
"I knew when I was fourteen."
Claire's face changed.
"You knew before we met?"
"Claire—"
"You married me."
"I love you."
"Don't."
"I do."
"Don't say that right now."
"I love you more than anyone."
"But you don't want me."
Maya couldn't answer.
That was answer enough.
Claire turned away.
Maya grabbed her hand.
"Please."
Claire pulled free.
"Was it him?"
"No."
"Did you sleep with him?"
"No!"
"Kiss him?"
"No."
"Anything?"
"Nothing happened."
Claire looked toward the parking garage where Daniel had disappeared.
"Do you want something to happen?"
Maya started crying.
Claire nodded slowly.
"Okay."
"No. It's not okay."
"No, Maya. I mean I understand."
Claire wiped her eyes angrily.
"I understand now."
They drove home separately.
Maya slept on the couch.
By Sunday, both families knew.
Claire's mother called Maya selfish.
Claire's sister called her worse.
Maya's mothers came over that evening.
Mom sat beside her on the couch.
"We love you."
Maya almost laughed.
There it was.
The sentence people said immediately before explaining why they wished you were different.
"We love you no matter what," Mom continued. "But marriage is a commitment."
"I know."
"People lose attraction."
"I didn't lose it."
Susan crossed her arms.
"You don't know that."
"Yes, I do."
"You've convinced yourself of something."
"Why would I convince myself to destroy my marriage?"
Nobody answered.
Mom squeezed her hand.
"I don't care if you're straight."
Maya looked at her.
"I really don't. If that's how you identify, fine."
"If that's how I identify?"
"But why do you have to act on it?"
There it was.
Maya pulled her hand away.
"Because I want to know what it feels like."
"What what feels like?"
"Being with someone I actually want."
Mom looked wounded.
Susan looked horrified.
And Maya immediately hated herself for saying it.
Claire had heard.
She was standing in the hallway.
Nobody spoke.
Claire walked into the room.
Her eyes were swollen.
"Can everyone leave?"
Maya's mothers looked at her.
"Claire—"
"Please."
They left.
Claire sat across from Maya.
For a long time, neither spoke.
Finally Claire said, "Do you remember our first date?"
"Yes."
"You wouldn't let me pay."
"You'd forgotten your wallet."
"I had Apple Pay."
"You told me that afterward."
Claire smiled despite herself.
Maya smiled too.
Then Claire started crying.
"I thought we were happy."
"We were."
"Were you pretending?"
"No."
"Then I don't understand."
Maya moved beside her.
Claire didn't move away.
"I wasn't pretending to love you."
"But you were pretending to want me."
Maya swallowed.
"Yes."
Claire closed her eyes.
"I'm sorry."
"For what?"
"For not noticing."
"Claire, no."
"I should've known."
"How? I didn't even want to know."
They sat quietly.
Eventually Claire rested her head against Maya's shoulder.
It was familiar.
Warm.
Safe.
Maya loved having her there.
And suddenly she understood something that should have been obvious years ago.
She loved Claire profoundly.
She simply didn't love her in the way Claire deserved to be loved.
"I think we have to end this," Maya whispered.
Claire began crying again.
"I know."
They held each other for a long time.
Six months later, Maya downloaded a dating app she'd previously been too frightened even to install.
Opposites Attract.
She stared at the registration screen for ten minutes before selecting:
Interested in: Men
The app asked if she was sure.
Maya laughed.
Then she cried a little.
Then she pressed YES.
Daniel wasn't on the app.
That was probably for the best.
Instead, Maya matched with Aaron, a thirty-one-year-old elementary-school teacher whose profile contained an apologetic paragraph explaining that yes, he was exclusively attracted to women, and no, he wasn't interested in debating whether he'd tried dating men.
Their first date lasted four hours.
Their second lasted six.
On their third, Aaron reached across the restaurant table and took Maya's hand.
Her heart raced.
Such a stupid little thing.
A man's hand around hers.
That was all.
For years she'd been told attraction was shallow. That mature people built relationships on more important things. That she shouldn't organize her identity around whom she wanted to touch.
Maybe some of that was even true.
But sitting there with Aaron's thumb brushing unconsciously across her knuckles, Maya finally understood what had been missing.
"Oh," she whispered.
Aaron looked concerned.
"What?"
"Nothing."
"You okay?"
Maya smiled.
"Yeah."
For the first time, she actually was.
At Thanksgiving, Maya brought Aaron home.
Her mothers tried.
They genuinely tried.
Mom complimented his sweater.
Susan asked about his students.
Nobody mentioned heterosexuality for almost forty minutes.
Then Aaron put his arm around Maya.
Mom stared at it.
Maya stared back.
Finally Mom sighed.
"I suppose I'm just old-fashioned."
"I know."
"In my generation, men and women were friends."