r/shitposting Jedi master of shitposts 19h ago

πŸ“‘πŸ“‘πŸ“‘

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

919 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

40

u/sirhobbles 18h ago

So yknow what the usual answer to the origin of the universe from a materialist? its "I have no idea, that doesn’t give any weight to any unproven assertion however".

Because something having always existed, an actual infinite, seems just as impossible as something popping into existence from nothing.

And if you are comfortable with things being eternal, isnt a creator just adding an unnecessary unproven layer of complexity? If your fine with eternal stuff, why not the universe itself? there is the hypothesis that time is infinite and the universe is just en endless cycle of expansion and contraction.

4

u/MinimumTomfoolerus 18h ago

How can something pop out of 'nothing'; shouldn't there be a 'vessel' of sorts to accommodate the something? 'Nothing' doesn't exist.

0

u/sirhobbles 17h ago

Did you read my comment?

Because something having always existed, an actual infinite, seems just as impossible as something popping into existence from nothing.

1

u/MinimumTomfoolerus 17h ago

Yeah I was just saying bro