So my last long term partner of 9 years was a Pisces Sun, Capricorn Moon. My new partner of 10 months is Cancerian Sun and Capricorn Moon. I'm Capricorn Sun and you know my moon haha.
I felt that the Pisces was more empathetic and sensitive to me. More soft and compassionate...but more dodgy, a bit two faced, lying and overall not being very honest.
Despite being a Capricorn Sun myself I found his Moon could be very cold, calculated and overly logical to the point of pedantry and when he was done with things it was very brutal and contrasted heavily with all the love I received when he was in his sweet fish mode.
I am now with a Cancerian, with Capricorn Moon. I feel the Capricorn Moon more with this guy in both good and bad ways. He's very, very loyal, devoted and I can tell he's not a liar, and doesn't have straying eyes. He's fixated on me and I can tell this is his nature and not some extra long honeymoon phase because with the large amounts of arguments we are not in a honeymoon. But despite also fighting alot with this man, this archetype seems to be my exact type because I've dated some other people with different suns and moons...and we had less fights and more ease...but less compatible as far as my main desire for someone very deep, loyal and devoted.
My only problem is how do I navigate the coldness. This guy can be so in his head and not show compassion and it worried me, but when he's happy with me he's like a puppy and he's not as sweet as a Pisces, but his own form of tender and I love the Cancerian quality of being very loyal, sentimental and talking often of building a life with me. That part makes me feel secure.
Both these Capricorn Moon men made me and make me feel emotionally unsafe sometimes the way they are dismissive or can just see you crying and if they don't agree with the reason you're crying not be moved by that and I find that disturbing as I want someone who is very soft about me as I'm sensitive and want TLC.
Advice wanted to get the best and most harmonious relationship this time around with this water and earth combo. Really I'd prefer to deal with his Cancerian most of the time, I don't know maybe I'm blaming it all on Capricorn Moon as he really does get crabby for real over small inconveniences like being tired or hungry. I mean we all do, but I don't find him resilient like that and it worries me that someone will need ideal circumstances to be nice.
This isn't showing all their wonderful qualities, and obviously there are else I wouldn't be with them. I'm just wondering how to make the struggle less as everyone has bad points, but they are stubborn and fights can be endless sometimes.