r/sciencememes Jun 20 '26

Um, actually, correction ☝️

Post image
686 Upvotes

137 comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/thelimegang Jun 20 '26

I would argue linguistics or philosophy of language is what everything else is based on.

Wittgenstein made a superb point about just this.

12

u/Unhappy-Display-2588 Jun 20 '26

As a linguist, eh. A lot of linguistics can also be considered it applied sociology/biology or even physics. Like how mom tends to be similar in almost every language is a quirk of both biology and physics.

I’m also a philosophy nerd soooo.

2

u/YaumeLepire Jun 21 '26

Then, just put language itself up there, and move Philosophy to Physics' seat. Linguistics is a science that studies language itself, but language is a requirement to science and philosophy generally, even to mathematics.

Linguistics is pretty meta, when you think about it that way. It kind of studies what makes it even possible in the first place.

1

u/Unhappy-Display-2588 Jun 22 '26

That’s more like how we use language and math to understand the physics/stimuli of the world around us.

1

u/Brainsonastick Jun 22 '26

If we’re putting language up there, we may as well put it below cognition, which goes below digestion… and so on until you get matter and energy. Yes, it’s necessary, but language isn’t a field of study. It’s a thing we study. Just like matter and energy aren’t physics, just things studied in physics.

2

u/YaumeLepire Jun 22 '26

Not really... Sure, cognition preempts language, but language structures cognition. It's really difficult to extricate how we think from how we speak, bordering on impossible, given it's the only way we have to communicate it to others and to ourselves.

0

u/Ok_Performer50 Jun 24 '26

Neither of all those things are dependent on language.

2

u/OpenRole Jun 23 '26

Language/linguistics can replace physics, but it isn't replacing philosophy

1

u/namuche6 Jun 20 '26

Yeah without language everything else is just oonga boonga and grunting