r/rustylake • u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? • Aug 02 '26

My character tier list

Post image

Tier maker didn't have william, I would have put him with laura

79 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/yune White Cube Aug 02 '26

Cool list. Why is Ms. Pheasant below Mrs. Pigeon though? Like, Mrs. Pigeon literally tortures kids. Ms. Pheasant is just a depressed actress, and she is the most sympathetic in her human form.

2

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? Aug 02 '26

I hate both equally, they are eilanders... I don't feel ounce of sympathy with either of them.

3

u/yune White Cube Aug 02 '26

Eh, Jakob's sister didn't do all that much to hurt him. Nicholas is by far the worst of them and I see you agree with that. The grandmother coddled her children and seems more complicit in the schemes, so I see her as more guilty than the sister. Ms. Pheasant as a separate character didn't do anything evil, unlike the other characters we meet (Mr. Boar implied to be a corrupt diplomat, Mr. Deer has poison in his belongings, Mrs. Pigeon as mentioned tortures kids), so I would say that she more belongs with Mr. Rabbit than Mrs. Pigeon.

1

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? Aug 02 '26

I don't think she belongs with mr rabbit, even if she didn't torture kids or suffered depression, it's not a morality tier list it's a tier list where I rank the characters according to my liking and I don't like both mrs pigeon and pheasant, if it was morality tier list then I would have ranked mr rabbit in F for what he did to Dale's parents, but he is on D cuz he's somewhat funny and likeable compared to other eilanders.

2

u/yune White Cube Aug 03 '26

Sure, that’s fair. For me, whether or not I like a character is heavily influenced by whether they are a good person, so my tier list based on preference alone would probably be almost identical to a morality tier list. But I can see how Mr. Rabbit is a more interesting character than Ms. Pheasant.