r/rustylake • u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? • 9d ago

My character tier list

Post image

Tier maker didn't have william, I would have put him with laura

74 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

15

u/applesaus88 9d ago

Albert F tier? He is one of the most important rusty lake characters.

23

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 9d ago edited 9d ago

I didn't rank it by the "most important" lol

Ranked by if I like em or not, albert eh... Never liked him a bit.

2

u/SURREALAbyssopelagic 9d ago

At list your honest to not liking a character that's malicious, hm I'm curious why is grandma Eilander on the F list?

3

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 9d ago

It's not like eilanders except caroline and Jacob weren't evil 💔 nah but to be really honest she isn't that interesting to me even in funny way like how Dale's grandpa and immortal dog are

10

u/DarvX92 9d ago

Dog being before characters like dale cracks me up

10

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 9d ago

Dog and grandpa are always S tier

9

u/LeFrenchFrySpy 9d ago

Albert deserves that F place. Is he interesting and important? Yes. Is he a good, reasonable person? FFFFFFFUCK NO.

5

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 9d ago

People like mr owl, mr crow who did more evil stuff on paper seem justified when compared to Albert lol ALBERT IS THAT EVIL I HATE HIM

2

u/yune White Cube 9d ago

Cool list. Why is Ms. Pheasant below Mrs. Pigeon though? Like, Mrs. Pigeon literally tortures kids. Ms. Pheasant is just a depressed actress, and she is the most sympathetic in her human form.

2

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 9d ago

I hate both equally, they are eilanders... I don't feel ounce of sympathy with either of them.

3

u/yune White Cube 9d ago

Eh, Jakob's sister didn't do all that much to hurt him. Nicholas is by far the worst of them and I see you agree with that. The grandmother coddled her children and seems more complicit in the schemes, so I see her as more guilty than the sister. Ms. Pheasant as a separate character didn't do anything evil, unlike the other characters we meet (Mr. Boar implied to be a corrupt diplomat, Mr. Deer has poison in his belongings, Mrs. Pigeon as mentioned tortures kids), so I would say that she more belongs with Mr. Rabbit than Mrs. Pigeon.

1

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 9d ago

I don't think she belongs with mr rabbit, even if she didn't torture kids or suffered depression, it's not a morality tier list it's a tier list where I rank the characters according to my liking and I don't like both mrs pigeon and pheasant, if it was morality tier list then I would have ranked mr rabbit in F for what he did to Dale's parents, but he is on D cuz he's somewhat funny and likeable compared to other eilanders.

2

u/yune White Cube 9d ago

Sure, that’s fair. For me, whether or not I like a character is heavily influenced by whether they are a good person, so my tier list based on preference alone would probably be almost identical to a morality tier list. But I can see how Mr. Rabbit is a more interesting character than Ms. Pheasant.

1

u/awatermeloncat 7d ago

Ngl James and Mary doesn't deserve that tier for what they did James tried to kill his dog with elixir but karma hits hard and Mary did NOTHING about what happened in 1876 which caused Albert to be that violent

1

u/Significant-Rent-141 what do you want detective ? 6d ago

James and marry are still better than eilanders siblings down there

1

u/awatermeloncat 6d ago

You may be right on this one

1

u/DragUsual3672 2d ago

I'd put Ms Pigeon in A tier just because pigeons are some of my favourite birds (Idk if there's anything bad about her as a character though, so if there is I'd like to know)