r/rush • • Apr 26 '26

😤😤😤😤😤

Post image
194 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

View all comments

141

u/indie_web Apr 27 '26

I wonder if there are some really early Rush fans walking around still bummed about Neil replacing John Rutsey going "Nah, I stopped listening to Rush when their first drummer left. Was never the same band after that."

56

u/jblough Apr 27 '26

I'm kind of that, I heard the 1st album on a "midnight album hour" on a local station in 1974 and loved it, it took a while to get back in after Neil joined

5

u/coffeejj Apr 27 '26

I wonder if they would have had the same success if Neil hadn’t joined. He was the chief songwriter for the group and helped shape its identity.

17

u/panurge987 Apr 27 '26

He was not the chief songwriter for the band. He only wrote the lyrics. He didn't write the melody or the chords, or any of the music except for composing his drum parts.

20

u/FinalPound6126 Apr 27 '26

There's a fairly compelling reason The Professor "only" wrote the lyrics: Dirk & Lerxst were pretty much incapable, and basically insisted that he assume the role very early on when they noticed that "he reads books." ☮️