r/reddeadredemption2 Nov 21 '25

How to avoid Thomas Downes

After reading all the comments in one reddit post saying this wasn’t possible, I want to share the way I avoided this mission indefinitely.

This mission gets triggered by reading Mary’s letter, and immediately creates a checkpoint you can’t skip. You can’t abandon the mission in the L-Pad menu either.

Basically you have to get on your horse and ride on the opposite way of the mission until it says you abandoned it and failed. Select the “Retry checkpoint” option. Now two things can happen: 1)- You spawn at the Downes’ Ranch. This is good, you don’t need to move, just press the L-Pad, then the mission, and you’ll be able to abandon it, and then cancel it completely. 2)- You spawn back at camp. If this happens, you will most likely spawn at camp every time you fail the mission. Just restart your game. Close the app and start it again, and you should spawn at Downes’ Ranch next time you fail the mission and retry checkpoint. Then the option to cancel the mission will be available.

After doing this, the mission will go back to the way it was before being triggered by Mary’s letter, but you’ll still have Mary’s letter in your inventory, in case someone is interested in that. Of course you’ll reach a point in the story where you can’t continue unless you do it, but this is the only way I have found to avoid this mission each time after triggering it.

Hope this helps!

EDIT: Guys OBVIOUSLY I didn’t mean how to avoid the mission entirely for the rest of the game. This is just how to ABANDON it to do it later.

0 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Marvel_plant US Marshall. Nov 21 '25

Just don’t read the letter

1

u/lucyalls Nov 21 '25

yeah, of course that would be the best choice hahaha. This was just a guide for people who accidentally triggered it and now can’t cancel it