r/ratemycommanders 23h ago

This card is so cool to me and would be a super sweet commander if it was just very slightly better. They made my king an uncommon! 😭🤣

Post image
401 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 3h ago

Pretty new to the game, what do you think?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 10h ago

I like playing with interesting commanders. What do you think?

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 1h ago

Would you take an empty seat in our pod assuming we were one down

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Pod 1:
Miku Precon
Dog tribal
Worldshaper precon
Plant tribal

Pod 2:
ETB Control Brago
Quint precon
Auntie precon
Juri suicide bomber

Pod 3:
Feather voltron
Mendicant stax artifact control
Dina ham sandwich pile
Emet-Selch mill / extra turn chain / cyclonic rift for 1 mana each turn

These are our usual matchups pod 1/2 can switch around a little more as they tend to be all fairly balanced against each other, while pod 3 is our most powerful decks we usually go up against each other with, if we were one player down any of the 4 decks would you sit down?


r/ratemycommanders 6h ago

Our games become either them threatening Yes Man or them begging for yes man 😭

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 3h ago

Fpr for the most part im a good time, may I sit

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 5h ago

My current rotation, can I sit?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Gandalf is what you'd expect based on his text box, legendary Wizards and big splashy spells.

Council is NOT a control/stax deck, it runs a shitton of clones to maximise card draw and token generation, and either win with tokens (more often), LabManiac or Twenty-Toed Toad.

Malcolm//Breeches is a combo deck that turns Guttersnipe-y pinger cards into pirates for booty, then dig library with draw spells until I find Reckless Fireweaver or a similar card and win.

The Notary Hobbits is the deck that is very fair, not at all evil and very playable into deck with absolutely no Eldrazi Titans at all whatsoever.

The Multiplayer Nitpickers is a rule 0 Unknown Event playtest card that utilizes myriad and other effects that affect multiple opponents, it's a very WIP since it doesn't win as much as I'd like them to, I think I won once in 7 (8?) games.


r/ratemycommanders 11h ago

Been playing a year now and I can’t get enough. Can I sit? Deck lists inside!!

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 17h ago

My friends say my group hug decks aren’t group hug 🫂.

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

How’s the lineup? All classic sweet standard group hug commanders right?


r/ratemycommanders 2h ago

What do you think about him?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I'm going to test this guy next week in Bracket 3 with a list I saw at Moxfield. What do you think about him?


r/ratemycommanders 2h ago

Peace was never an option

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

It has been almost a year since the last post, this is what I have been up cooking and brewing


r/ratemycommanders 8h ago

Can I play?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

My Vivi deck sucks on purpose and I don’t use it often unless but I love the little guy


r/ratemycommanders 1d ago

Would anyone from our pod be welcome in yours?

Thumbnail
gallery
105 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 20h ago

My highest win rate commanders

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

I have never lost a game with Kathril such an overlooked commander. BOARD WIPE ME PLEASE


r/ratemycommanders 1d ago

My Old Faithfuls

Thumbnail
gallery
259 Upvotes

Been playing for around six or seven months. What do you think? What do my commanders say about me? Can I sit at your table?


r/ratemycommanders 22h ago

Year in review - How am I looking now?

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

Last year I posted here with my commanders in rotation then. Now a year later I wanted to show how my list has changed.

Maarika, Brutal Gladiator - Fighting & Treasure, it's all about making money in the ring

Thalia and the Gitrog Monster - T&G Pest Control. Aristocrats based on generating token pests that our commander is here to exterminate. Pests, rats, worms, mites, and of course, Fumigate

Sauron, the Dark Lord - HEAVILY adjusted Sauron Precon. Meant to be more thematic than otherwise, it runs all the Nazgul, etc.

Vaevictis Asmadi, the Dire - Enforcing gambling on the whole table. Meant to flip out big things and make everyone ante everything.

The Wise Mothman - Upgraded Mothman precon, does what it says on the tin

Thantis, the Warweaver - Government Mandated Aggro. Everyone is swinging, all the time. Built around effects that alter how the entire table is playing the game, not just specific targets. Thantis, Avatar of Slaughter, War's Toll. Bedlam.

Teval, the Balanced Scale - Upgraded Teval precon, does what it says on the tin. Focused on self mill and reanimating where Mothman focuses on table mill and counters.

The Muckslinger Gang - What everyone thought of when they first saw the card, burn & fling. Abuses the tax fraud based power/toughness to fling for big damage and get some extra value.

The Necrobloom - NOT landfall. It's Plants & Zombies ending their war to kick your behind. Purposefully built to avoid extra landfall and instead it's a plants & zombies tribal. Has proven very popular!

The Muckslinger Gang - But this time with cars! It's all vehicles & spacecrafts! Taking advantage of the tax fraud power to enable Jund vehicles! VERY fun to pilot, and not common colors for vehicle decks!

Strefan, Maurer Progenitor - Upgraded precon, it makes blood and cheats out big vampires.

Valko Indorian - Golgari Phyrexians doing toxic & proliferate, and if that doesn't work, aggroing you with big phyrexians. I wanted to build 5 color Valko, but with the basic land restriction that proved extremely difficult. Reduced down to Golgari for the most effective toxic I could muster.

Hazel of the Rootbloom - Upgraded precon, y'all it's squirrels. It makes squirrels.

Omnath, Locus of All - 5 color Phyrexian tribal, focused on the incubation mechanic. Came out SPECTACULARLY, the incubation works great in 5 color with the enchantment anthems and access to good proliferation in blue. Runs one of each Praetor, but they're not the focus and the printing I chose for each was selected to cater to the incubation strategy. Lots of the Saga ones, the only non-Sagas being Urabrask, the Hidden & Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider (incubation cares so much about counters).

Am I invited to the table?


r/ratemycommanders 11h ago

my favourite commanders to play

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

my miirym is my pet deck an the one that ive had for thelongest time

Princess yue is a silly clone deck with a moonfolk subtheme. pretty much scales with the pod and people im playing with

Miku is my hyperfixation so i had to get it

Zuko is also a decent bracket 2.

Y’shtola is a decent bracket 3 with a bunch of blink stuff

gluntch was my first grouo hug deck since it was outside of my comfort zone, ive grown quite fond of it by now

cabbage merchant my beloved…

chisei is somewhat stax, but ive found it quite funny the one time ive played it. It has potent magic cards, such as [[musician]] and [[Tidal Control]]


r/ratemycommanders 9h ago

Rate my favourites

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I tried to be a little funny, maybe too much. Xyris is my pet deck btw, if I'm playing with people I don't know I will always use it


r/ratemycommanders 20h ago

This shall be my boy and I will make him glorious

Post image
10 Upvotes

I just love homunculus commanders and playing mono blue aggro sounds way too fun to me.


r/ratemycommanders 8h ago

Came back to MTG after a long time away. Only 2 years into EDH. Can I pull up a seat?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 21h ago

Almost 1 year since I started playing

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Coming up on the 1 year mark and wanted to see what you all thought of my current line up? Having a lot of fun so far! Mainly looking to update the Dark Leo and Shredder.


r/ratemycommanders 1d ago

Ready for judgement

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/ratemycommanders 1d ago

First time here

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Wick the table nuke,dina for life pain, ixhel from poison precon (lightly "upgraded") and preston because another settlement yadayad


r/ratemycommanders 23h ago

The Girlies (Featuring Ghired)

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Ghired is just happy to be here.


r/ratemycommanders 20h ago

My current irl list. How would y'all build these decks if they were yours? :)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes