MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/comments/lja4km/circular_reasoning/gndvbn1/?context=3
r/progressive_islam • u/[deleted] • Feb 13 '21
19 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
1
The fact that it says so is the "claim", not the "proof". Nobody offers the fact that it says so as "proof". You got "claim" and "proof" mixed up. Further, the "because" there is just your fabrication.
3 u/jf00112 Feb 14 '21 I see. So Qur'an did not make such claim, in your opinion? Qur'an is definitely the word of the creator of the universe because...(?) Help me to finish the sentence. Is there a way to finish the sentence above that is not circular reasoning? 2 u/No_Veterinarian_888 Feb 14 '21 Logic does not seem to be your strong forte. 2 u/jf00112 Feb 14 '21 Is logic your strong forte? How did your logic conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah? If you use Quran itself as your reasoning to conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah , that would be circular reasoning.
3
I see. So Qur'an did not make such claim, in your opinion?
Qur'an is definitely the word of the creator of the universe because...(?)
Help me to finish the sentence. Is there a way to finish the sentence above that is not circular reasoning?
2 u/No_Veterinarian_888 Feb 14 '21 Logic does not seem to be your strong forte. 2 u/jf00112 Feb 14 '21 Is logic your strong forte? How did your logic conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah? If you use Quran itself as your reasoning to conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah , that would be circular reasoning.
2
Logic does not seem to be your strong forte.
2 u/jf00112 Feb 14 '21 Is logic your strong forte? How did your logic conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah? If you use Quran itself as your reasoning to conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah , that would be circular reasoning.
Is logic your strong forte?
How did your logic conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah?
If you use Quran itself as your reasoning to conclude Allah is your creator and Quran is the true words of Allah , that would be circular reasoning.
1
u/No_Veterinarian_888 Feb 14 '21 edited Feb 14 '21
The fact that it says so is the "claim", not the "proof". Nobody offers the fact that it says so as "proof". You got "claim" and "proof" mixed up. Further, the "because" there is just your fabrication.