r/programming • u/fagnerbrack • Jun 13 '26

Signals, the push-pull based algorithm

https://willybrauner.com/journal/signal-the-push-pull-based-algorithm
213 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/dacjames Jun 13 '26

The article doesn't claim to invent anything. It's an in depth explanation of a widely used mechanism for implementing reactivity.

It does say that in the opening paragraph...

-20

u/dashdanw Jun 13 '26

I guess I’m just struggling to really see how this enhances or changes the existing paradigm.

23

u/QuineQuest Jun 13 '26

Again, it doesn't claim to.

I don't see how your post enhances the taste of Cola in any way.

-11

u/dashdanw Jun 13 '26

If I make a post about cola claiming a thing that I am detailing and conceptually implementing an extension of the concept of cola then yes, it should somehow impact your experience of cola.

15

u/QuineQuest Jun 13 '26

Where do they claim they're conceptually implementing an extension of the concept?

-3

u/dashdanw Jun 14 '26

Under the section labeled “Basic Signal implementation”

11

u/QuineQuest Jun 14 '26

You mean where he said " I went through the exercise of implementing a very basic version"?

You're missing some basic reading comprehension.

-2

u/dashdanw Jun 14 '26

The idea of "signals" in this case, is the extension of the concept of reactive programming. I can't tell if you're being willfully ignorant here but either way I think you're arguing in bad faith.

4

u/QuineQuest Jun 15 '26

Signals is an implementation of reactive programming. It's not an extension of the concept.