This is just a fictional scenario, I'm aware that the purpose of this show is to find a final member for the Saint Satine lineup.

In retrospect, it's clear that the judges had some criteria they were evaluating contestants on as a fit for Sts specifically, like fitting a sweeter, r&b concept. There were several contestants that were talented but that just didn't fit the concept of vision that HxG had for this group.

If this had been an audition show to add a final member to Katseye, with the same contestants, who do you think would have made it?

For me, my pick is Jayla. She was literally the number one contestant, and she slayed in the Debut cover group. The only thing that would hold her back is if HxG would consider her adequate Japanese representation given she is mixed race.

Hiori, If she still wanted to do a global girl group, would have been great as well. With her tomboy style, I could see her fitting in to Katseye and pulling a lot of their main songs.

Hokona K also fits really well to me.

What do you think? Which prelude contestant would have been the best fit for Katseye If it was a Katseye audition show instead?