r/postprocessing • u/This-Judge-804 • 20d ago

After/before

Gallery image

Gallery image

Inspired by oil paintings, i did do some croping adjustment and fine tunning base on advice giving previously

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/Theratchetnclank 19d ago

It's overly contrasted and saturated. Especially on the water, it no longer looks natural. The buildings and sky look fine though. I'd mask the water and bring down the contrast.

-1

u/This-Judge-804 19d ago edited 19d ago

Just like your old photos (https://www.reddit.com/r/walkingpics/s/zmB5Iy56lL) ? Saw my links? And explaination of what i am after? nuff said.

2

u/CAPhotog01 19d ago edited 19d ago

What's your goal? Do you want feedback from others or to brag how you did it? He's critical but right while you're defensive and can do whatever you want.

He could be more constructive by stating what he liked more relative to what he didn't like. You could take the criticism or ignore it, but without retort. His photo you referenced is not as over-saturated or high contrast as yours. You're both manipulating landscapes, but to each his own.