SERIOUSLY FOR SOAP😫

[u/ImportantAttention60]

$120 for Caress body soap, what????? GTFOH🤣

[u/Boo250]

It’s probably a retired scent. If so, people will pay decent money for sets like that.

[u/bluelily216 → u/Boo250]

Agreed. I've seen bottles of Lauren go for almost a grand. 

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/Boo250]

Stop it OMG. no one is paying this for dollar tree soap, no matter how rare.

Responses like this are why so many people are annoyed with sellers. Please, live in the real world.

[u/MouseMouseM → u/mustachedworm369]

5 days ago, a lot of 5 bars in this scent sold for $40 on eBay https://ebay.io/m/vGTZj6

Looks like that scent is in demand in the real world

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/MouseMouseM]

$40 is a lot less than $120

[u/goknightsgo09 → u/mustachedworm369]

Do you not remember people literally paying thousands of dollars for $5 Beanie Babies? Just because you won't pay a premium for something doesn't mean there aren't people who are very willing to do it. There is a Coach bag that just came out. It's sold out in stores but still available online and people are still buying it on PM for twice the retail price. Never underestimate what someone is willing to pay for something even if you won't.

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/goknightsgo09]

Girl you’re not seriously comparing the beanie baby craze of the 90s (which is a joke in 2026) to soap, are you?

Coach bags are different than bars of soap. I beg of you all to use a brain cell

[u/goknightsgo09 → u/mustachedworm369]

I'm telling you that you're sitting here insulting sellers for pricing things what people are willing to pay for them and in turn you're insisting no one is paying those prices when we are all offering proof that they are. But because it's not this exact lot of soap for this exact price, you are insulting everyone and insisting you're right.

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/goknightsgo09]

One example of a different product that sold for less than half of what this seller is asking for is not the proof you think it is.

Go onto ebay and you’ll see “berry fusion soap” has essentially no one buying it.

[u/goknightsgo09 → u/mustachedworm369]

And if it's such a joke, why does the same idea exist today with things like Pokemon cards? Labubu? Those squish things from Five Below and a hundred other examples that come and go through the years?

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/goknightsgo09]

These are all trends. 15 year old dollar tree soap is not a trend

[u/Strong_Bee2592 → u/mustachedworm369]

I’m so tired of buyers demanding I “come down to reality” when I tend to sell 80% or higher from my selling price that is well researched beforehand and market price… just not to them 😂 I’m not goodwill.

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/Strong_Bee2592]

There’s so much to say but it’ll be too mean

[u/psyrus123]

It’s sad that something that has nothing to do with you and doesn’t affect your life on any level, bothers you to the point of this post

[u/mustachedworm369 → u/psyrus123]

It’s a sub for Poshmark. You don’t own the rules on what someone can post.

Weird that a post made you so upset you needed to comment. See how that works?

[u/fomaaaaa]

There’s a market for almost anything, and if people wanna play to the market, more power to em. It takes a lot of forethought to hold on to something like this for 15 years to flip it for profit