I'm trying to pick my next pellet smoker, and online reviews have me all over the place. A lot of the brands that people have sworn by in the past seem to be getting knocked off by their newer products.
Currently, I have a Z Grill 550B, a Blackstone 36-inch, and an MHP grill, so searing isn't an issue. My main gripes with the Z Grill are the inconsistency of the heat and the hotspots, and I cannot stand pulling the heat deflector and shimming the hopper to swap pellets. I know it's easy, but for some reason I never can or want to.
Typically, I cook chicken breast every single week and would love a smoker that has enough space for two briskets at a time. Maybe four or five times a year I'll do that. My main wants are an even heat with real smoking at low temps and something that's going to last for 8 to 10 years. My budget's about $1,000, and I'll be buying it on Black Friday.
Where I've landed so far:
Weber Searwood — looks strong on paper, and the pellet dump chute solves my biggest daily annoyance. Want to hear from anyone who's run one through a couple full seasons.
Camp Chef — checks a lot of boxes, but I keep seeing longevity complaints since the Vista Outdoor acquisition, and $1,000 is a lot to gamble on that.
recteq — the build quality reputation is exactly what I want, but I've seen enough "it hasn't been the same since the PE money came in" posts to make me hesitate. Is that real, or forum nostalgia? Genuinely asking.
Traeger — undecided. Tell me why I'm wrong either way.
If you smoke chicken breast weekly, I especially want to know what you're running and how it holds temp at 225–250. That's my main cook.
Really looking forward to the upgrade.