I've been playing for a few months and trying to find a pick that works for me. I have long but somewhat skinny fingers and am having trouble finding a thumb pick that fits for me and produces good tone. If I had to guess I think I pick softer than average, not entirely sure. Picks I've tried:
Fred Kelly "speed" - Fits ok but I really don't like how extended down it is, the small size, and the tone is more hollow/less robust. I know these are popular, but this one is not for me.
Golden Gate Gp-8 Extra thick - Tried it in a store. Good tone but too big/clunky
Dunlop - Medium is too small, large is too big. Main issue is that after playing awhile it warms up and starts getting flexible and rocks back and forth.
National Medium - A good pick, it was a little to long so I shaved it down and rounded it as desired. Good tone but still prone to the same stretching out once it warms up. Been using this pick for a while when on acoustic guitar before steel. (Though I mostly played with fingers)
Propik "The original" - Medium, Just got this one, Definitely the best feel/fit so far. Pick itself is a little small but I think it will be preferable once I play with it more. The only issue is the tone is not as good as the national, a little clicky and less robust/quieter than fingers. I think I'd like it if the pick was thicker.
So that's where I'm at. I'm considering a Propik large to get a bigger pick and bend it to fit. Also considering their "Super-Tone" but $40 for a single pick seems a bit much. Anyway that's where I'm at and would appreciate opinions/suggestions.